SoxBlanco

But but but...this is the third time since 2016 that this has happened!! Three times in about 8,000 games! We should definitely be basing our base running decisions on that. I cant even believe I have to argue this. It’s not even debatable. No chance it was Tim’s fault.

You keep calling your three reasons solid, and they just aren’t. 1. Anderson is not getting thrown out at second if he tags. Zero chance. Terrible first reason. 2. This reason sucks, too. That ball was not going to fall in the field of play. Was 99% a mythical number? Absolutely. But I was trying to get the point across that that ball was either going to be a home run or be caught. I’m not sure how you could watch that play and think otherwise. Did you notice how Anderson started by going halfway? Then as the LF was starting to settle at the wall, he ran back to tag. That’s because Timmy has baseball instincts, which you clearly don’t. 3. You saved the worst reason for last. And that’s saying a lot, considering how terrible your first two reasons were. You actually think a baserunner should consider whether the runner behind might pass him when determining what to do? Ridiculous. The funniest part about your post is that you said, “Learn baseball and think.” You obviously have no baseball sense.

Those three reasons were not solid, and you absolutely tag up in that situation. The ball was hit very high. In that situation, there’s a 99% chance that the ball is either caught or it leaves the park. Anderson did the right thing by going back to tag. I said as much in the game thread, and I stick by it. There is no way that is Timmy’s fault.

What happens next? Basabe to AA? EDIT: A minute after posting this, I read that Basabe is heading to AA.

I think they would take Witt. Gut feeling.

He did miss some right down the middle. He was clearly mad at himself. They were all around 95 mph.

Beat you to it by a couple seconds. ?

Because he was tagging up. If the LF catches that with his back against the wall, Anderson tags and is at second base. If it’s a home run, he scores anyway. It was a smart play.

Exactly. The fact that so many people have criticized Timmy is amazing to me. Not a lot of baseball smarts here.

How are you guys blaming Tim? He was tagging up, but the ball was so high. That’s not his fault.

I’m no doctor, but I don’t believe a broken hand puts somebody out for four months. Sounds like bullshit to me.

If you think Tilson has a chance to be better, why not keep getting him regular at bats in AAA? Neither Tilson or Engel are going to start over Eloy, Leury, or Cordell, so you might as well keep Engel on the team as a better defensive replacement/4th outfielder and let Tilson get his at bats in Charlotte.

Not our Burdi, but yes.

Bumping this thread after another solid relief appearance (2 scoreless, 5 K’s, 0 BB’s). When do you expect he will be stretched out to a starter again? Will it happen in Winston-Salem, or will they promote him to Birmingham first and have him return to starting there?

Another scoreless inning for Hansen with two K’s, and 8 of his 14 pitches were for strikes.

This is a solid post. Well done.

Speaking of Lency Delgado, where is he playing this year? I haven’t heard much talk about him in a while.

With Moncada in the lineup twice, we’d never lose a game.

I've been wondering about this for a couple years now. Thanks for asking. Anybody have the answer?

In a perfect world, do Robert and Madrigal both get called up in mid-April next year?

15-pitch perfect inning with two K’s. 11 of the 15 were strikes.

Another option is to send Basabe to Charlotte when he's healthy. I've touched on this before, but would they consider moving Robert straight to AAA?

Yeah, he's an interesting player. I keep expecting him to fade, and he just keeps producing. I suppose he did fade a little last year after moving up to AA, so we'll see if he can sustain the nice year he is having so far. I think he has an outside shot at becoming a 4th outfielder at the big league level.

Do you think Booker moves up to AAA when Robert gets promoted?

The first name I think of when I hear that description of not playing baseball until later in life is Tim Anderson, and he continues to get better. Which specific White Sox draft picks are you thinking about?