But that could very well be a reason the Sox give Reed the first shot. Skole has no future with the Sox due to his age. The Sox have given Engel numerous chances. He can play defense but he can’t hit in the majors. Also, the Sox have an opening at DH now and in the near future. We already know who the long-term solution is for CF.
But I agree with you. After Palka failed for the second time, if the Sox decide to send Collins back down they should give the DH position to either Yermin or Reed.