I don’t see how you can say this. Money is money and $9 million is a lot of it. The Indians won the trade. Non contenders make trades all the time. Just because neither team wins the division, you can’t judge who won a trade between them? Ridiculous.
And what Caufield said is true, Alonso’s decline started in the second half of last season with the Indians so there were indicators that he would be bad. Also, how serviceable is a 1B/DH with a .738 OPS last year anyways? Definitely not starting DH material which is what Hahn did with him.
Hahn got clowned in this deal. It’s okay to admit it and it’s not like it hasn’t happened before in a much worse fashion. Look no further than the Padres two new franchise players.