poppysox

I agree with you. Don't ask players to pick the boss. Some of the best managers in history were in your face guys who were not trying to buddy up with the players. We all have credited RR with his friendly clubhouse, etc. Maybe a stronger hand will get better results.

I wish there was a way to get Alomar's boss (Francona).

It was implied.

The qualifiers that RH stated eliminate just about everyone not named Cora or Hinch. Who are the available managers with recent postseason success? My first choice would have been Jirschele but he was already eliminated by the RH remarks. I think we better get comfortable with Hinch.

Winning franchises are worth more than losers. JR knows it's time to prepare his teams to attract top dollar for his investors and heirs.

I was trying to agree with you. I don't doubt that AJ Pierzynski would be a really fun manager for us.

Doesn't fit with what RH said but I wish the other AJ would be considered. He is a very smart baseball guy who really wants to win.

He would be great but his new contract ties him up for 4 or 5 years. Managers can be bought out I guess but unlikely in this case. Definitely the right type though.

Yeah...he was crusty. Probably why I like him.

I liked Lamont. Really nice guy. Leland and Tanner were also very good baseball people. All of them knew how to fill out a lineup card. Billy Martin was the best one year manager but always wore out his welcome. I would like to have an old school manager who gets mad on occasion.

JR always said letting Hawk fire Larussa was his biggest regret. Normally I would agree that Tony is past his prime...but with JR he might want to correct what he considers a mistake. Hope not!

Wow...is Dave Duncan coming with him?

We live in a society that believes in 2nd chances after one has paid his debt to society.

Yeah...I am sure Soxtalk will give whoever it is a good week or 10 days before they can't take it any longer.?

It seems that many established managers have their pitching coach who follows them from job to job. They don't leave it to chance that they can work well together.

I would expect any high-end manager to insist on having total discretion in his coaching staff.

Thankfully Hahn is not waiting to find out if he is next. I think what we are seeing is JR knows this is his last shot and loyalty be damned...he wants to go out on top. RR seems to be a great guy but his lineups could have been improved on by most people on this board. In sixty-plus years of watching this team...I don't believe there was ever a worse job of handling the pitching staff than that game 3 display.

That third playoff game left the FO with the same feeling it left most of us with. Anyone with anything to do with how the staff was handled for game 3 is out.

Yeah...I was actually trying to point out that experienced managers are not going to be saddled with existing coaches. Girardi was a poor example but given that the Phillies have a new GM...you never know. Since we now know that Coop is out...the point is moot.

I would love Jirschele as the manager with Zaleski as pitching coach.

For sure if Gerardi gets the job... he absolutely is picking his own staff. A young guy like Jirschele might have to swallow a Coop but the top tier guys will insist on picking their own people.

It is a rare game that Engel doesn't contribute something. Defense and speed play a big role in winning many games. We need both starting & relief pitching as much as we can find.

Colome won't come close. Sox will make a solid offer of maybe 12 or 13 per season for probably two years.

When a regular Joe leaves his employer...he is well-advised to leave gracefully with thanks for the opportunity and best wishes. He might need a reference or his old job back one day. Also, don't bring your kids to work...doesn't work out well.

You make some solid points. I prefer keeping both Grandall and McCann but as always...money talks.