Player who have an edge to them often play for winners. Ty Cobb, Billy Martin, Early Wynn and AJ all had that edgy personality and I wonder if it didn't contribute to keeping their teammates heads in the game. I know that I'm guilty of liking my "nice" players and was recently thinking how likeable most of our players are. We always see TV shots of players fooling around happily in the dugout or playing mouse ears when on base. Maybe we need a couple of edgy players to keep us focused.