Right now it's easier to say that, but at the time there was uncertainty about his health. Carlos pitched 132 innings for us in 2021, he's at 116 and counting for the Giants.
Prior to 2021 he only pitched 41 innings in 2019 to 2020 so if it was my money I'm not giving Carlos an 18 mil QO or the 44 million he eventually signed for.
I hope he turns it around this year, but it's beginning to look like he's trending toward another dead arm come August-September.