Sorry to skip over the 6 pages of whatever you guys were arguing about, but as the Unofficial Soxtalk Metallica Representative, the dishonorable mention about St. Anger is ludicrious.
This has nothing to do about how good or bad the album was, it has to do with Metallica selling millions and millions of album for over 20 years. They have every right to make a new album.
How about the lame ass American Idol jibronies? There were probably thousands of other albums that should of never been made.
Ok, I'm done.