Literally anyone other than me would have been better off getting those ABs than Moose. He played 1B, why not let Elko get some more ABs? He played 3B, why not let Ramos get some more ABs?
And if the argument truly is that it was meant to push or replace Sheets, well that just brings it back to the Royals connection. Perhaps you could have gotten someone that would be a little more of a threat than the soon-to-be-out-of-baseball pal of Getz.