Can’t argue with you about Painter. Not so sure about Caba. He’s still super young and it was only a very small sample size but he struggled moving to Single A and also appears to have Madrigal power. I don’t think you can have Caba as the top position prospect you get back for Crochet. The lineup is pretty much devoid of any talent, and definitely of star players.
I think I’d rather see Getz go after more developed position prospects around the age of 21 or so. He really cannot f*** this up, or else there is no hope for a decent Sox lineup for years.