You are wrong. Look at their stats again.
Also, take a look at which player performed better in a very tiny sample size and which player was worse in 301 plate appearances.
Also take a look at which player is 2 years younger.
Google isn’t that difficult.
Obviously, they could both be bad. But I’ll give a chance to the 24-year old outfielder with plus power when our current outfielders are Benintendi, Taylor, Tauchman, Slater, and Jankowski — basically a pile of my son’s old crusty socks.