WhiteSox2023

I don’t think the 3-year max window Robert could be here is quite long enough to fit the Sox window to be competitive again. Plus, you always have to worry about his next injury. I still think he is traded before we find out what kind of season he has. But in your scenario, I think he would then be traded at the 2025 trade deadline.

If Getz can move Robert for a good SS prospect, you can always slide Montgomery over to 3B eventually and improve the defense on the entire left side. Colson is a pretty big dude at 6’3”, 225 and may be better suited for 3B in the long run.

It could be, but more than likely Robert will be traded before Montgomery makes the majors. Benintendi might be gone as well via a swap of bad contracts / salary dump, if Jerry has his way and Getz finds a willing suitor.

I don’t know about all that but hopefully he’s a genetic splice of Dustin Pedroia and Kevin Youkilis. It would be nice if he can be a legit starter at 2B. It would also be nice to get a legit SS or CF prospect for Robert now.

Crawford from the Phillies or Arroyo from the Reds would be nice. Sucks that Robert had such a down year that those guys are a stretch in a one-for-one trade.

Curious to see what other teams were offering, if those offers leak out.

I wonder what the offers are for him and what Getz is expecting.

And where is the evidence of this? I must have missed these posts.

Yeah, but like @Bob Sacamano said, that didn’t happen. Is it possible that this is the first big trade that the majority of posters think Getz won right from the beginning / on paper?

Would have liked to see them take another shot at someone. Do we really need Julks or Shewmake on the roster?

In this very page, @Sleepy Harold just posted an Athletic article from a few hours ago that states that the Phillies offered the White Sox SS Aidan Miller, CF Justin Crawford, and lower-level prospects for Crochet at last year’s trade deadline. That seems to be fairly comparable to what the Red Sox gave up today, even if the additional pieces were “lower-level”.

Here is the tweet. I doubt he would be happy with the Chicago media, even though the local baseball beat reporters are pretty bad at their jobs.

Only $9 bucks plus shipping…

My guess is that the third and fourth prospects in that Phillies offer were a far drop off from Meidroth and Gonzalez. Interesting though if true.

From reading the feedback from the majority of posters here. Go back to the initial trade thread. The majority was not thrilled with the return. And if you are asking if I did a scientific poll, no I did not. Just like I don’t need to come up with a list of people who liked the Fletcher or Vargas trades. The majority was expecting a greater return.

“Yankees acquired RHP Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz and international signing bonus pool money from the Red Sox for C Carlos Narváez. The interesting wrinkle here is the international bonus pool money, which could factor into the impending Roki Sasaki sweepstakes. Rodriguez-Cruz was a fourth-round pick in the 2021 MLB Draft and has yet to pitch above High-A. He’s a lottery ticket for the Yankees.”

I doubt that is enough to make him want to sign with the worst team in baseball.

@fathom be sweatin’… 😓

Rumor is Triston Casas for Luis Castillo.

Here’s MLB’s updated list: https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/whitesox

There’s probably a higher chance that Getz will sign Mike Clevinger for a third straight year, prompting @Balta1701 to leave the forum for another season.

Peak mlb poopline 💩 Paging @hi8is…

I wouldn’t be surprised if that is Getz’s target, as well as expecting Montgomery to eventually be at 3B. Sadly, I doubt Jacob Gonzalez is our SS of the future.

“There are reasons Montgomery went 12th in the draft. The health thing is a bit of a concern.” Did Montgomery have any health issues other than the broken ankle he sustained with an awkward slide home against Oregon? He was talked about being drafted as high as in the top four. The draft was right after his broken ankle and he was still drafted 12th. Weird thing to say.