QUOTE(Dam8610 @ Jan 5, 2006 -> 10:00 PM)
I have to disagree. When James was doing all the heavy lifting for the offense, it was because teams were playing to not let Manning beat them. Once they stopped doing that, Manning put up similar numbers to what he had last year. There is no other QB in the NFL that could run the Colts' offense IMO, and certainly no one else could make it as efficient as Manning does. To me, that makes him the MVP of the Colts at the very least.
True. I just think James really proved his worth a lot to this team this year, and we HAVE to retain him.