GreenSox

Agree. The zeal for 1 year players is bizarre. And Yolmer is a solid utility guy who should improve and who's numbers would be much better if used more judiciously. He's Marwin Gonzales but for that 1 freak year.

Probably not, but I have no idea how JR does his budgets. We aren't talking purely about money here. Grienke will cost prospects; maybe he shouldn't but he will. Also, it's premature - we don't know what the holes on the team will be. Frankly not one prospect has firmly established himself as a real starter going forward. Yea you can say Moncada and Anderson....but if they don't improve, they are average players. They aren't there yet. I'd also like to see them move Abreu. The Sox have I believe 6 really good OF prospects; I would like to see them trade from that for a pre arb or top prospect. Just a lot of work they can do on this roster. In the meantime, watching Yolmer again doesn't bother me...he probably won't get much better, but he might.

Because those moves would cost resources and the Sox would still be a bad team.

That won't work if they don't develop a group of 5-10 quality young players And as of now, they aren't close to that.

I like this, but I doubt the Sox will do it.

How is Wood a salary dump if Nova wasn't? Wood is younger, better and cheaper. A lot of the good teams are trying to get ahead of the game and trade their rentals, just like the rebuilders do. The OF would also likely be a 1 year player. The Sox need to stop giving talent for that stuff.

Thanks, yes.

Moncada would set the Sox up well. But as per above he doesn't have the star power, Harper has.

I am worried that this FO will do any number of silly trades for 1/2 year veterans.

They better be sure Collins can't catch. If he can, moving him to 1B devalues him; and trading him now is not exactly trading high.

Why don't the Dodgers want him back?

Because that's excessive.

Yes, they not only have to high-bid, they have to convince the player that Williams, Hahn and Renteria can turn this into a winning operation. That's no easy feat of salesmanship.

.607 career OPS. What's the point?

I hope they don't lose anyone, esp. considering the AAAA fodder they protected on the 40. They could pick a reliever, but they have a ton of equivalent guys on the 40. Same with 4th/5th OFs. I doubt they pick anyone.

The Sox should be open and up front with them about their plans while recruiting them. And the plan is that they have about 10 grade A prospects who will be matriculating in the next year or 2, and another 10 grade Bs and with that they will forge a winner hopefully starting in 2020. And if they trade Abreu, they will explain to them why they did it. These guys aren't signing here to win next year. Or put another way, if winning next year is a priority for them, they aren't signing with the White Sox.

I don't see what difference it makes. He's a 1 year player. Trade him if value is offered. Sox are still in that mode, and will be (or should be) for the next year. Sox aren't going to be any good next year, regardless of Harper/Machado.

This belongs more in the "Creative trades" thread, but I couldn't find it. Anyway, for my money, the 2018 Sox pitcher of the year was Jayce Fry. He's got 4 or 5 pitches. Kd a lot of guys; excellent WHIP. Reminds me a lot of MB - he throws that filthy stuff could be a really good control lefty. I hate trading good pitching. But I'm a sell-high and buy low guy. The Cubs need a lefty reliever...the only one they have is the Chef, Justin Wilson and he's pretty awful. So to that end, Jayce Fry for Ian Happ.

I thought that was a different Jordan. Yes, Jordan Guerrero

Even if I bought a Yankee stadium excuse (which I don't ) that's still a bad trade. Stephens is one of our better pitching prospects (I know the cw is that this org is replete with pitching, but it isn't). Yolmer is a very viable utility player. Sox are in no position to trade any talent for 1 year players.

For 1 year of Gray and his 1.5 WHIP and 4.9 ERA? Gray is a salary dump.

2 years of control. That certainly fits the window of contention.

Any of those except for Grandal would be okay. But only do a couple. Grandal would be terrible.

Agree. The Sox really can't start trading prospects because they don't know what they have yet.. Take CF - 3 good prospects, but they don't know which will be good (and their track record on evaluating such things isn't the best).

He's had one good year; otherwise, he is Leury et al.