GreenSox

Sox always seem to be just below what it takes to get the guy they need. Regardless of the level of what it takes to get the guy. JR doesn't trust his FO is all I can think.

Fulmer had a violent, non-repeatable, delivery such that the chances of him backing up in the pros were very high. Everyone/team/scout knew that his delivery would have to be smoothed out for him to succeed. His upside was never worth the risk. Rodon, honestly, never seemed like he was all that interested being a major league pitcher. I hope things change for him elsewhere.

Lopez could probably be a good reliever. He's a lot cheaper, and better, than the next Cishek.

Last season, Engel was significantly better against righties than lefties (but he was still good against lefties); the prior year was the opposite (and he wasn't good against righties). Those are the only 2 years to really judge because it has been in those 2 years that he has made such a dramatic improvement on offense. Heck, he may become starter quality soon.

He's fine (if they can't get Springer) but they'll need to get him a platoon partner. And the nice thing about that is that now you have a bench bat, something that the Sox had last year with McCann, but have rarely had over the years.

They got 2 of those guys through rebuilding trades; Steiver is the only pitcher in the rotation or near-term prospect that they got from drafting, so I'm not so sure how easy it is for this organization. And you need some depth as well. Giolito, Keuchel, Cease, Dunning, Lopez (who probably should be in the pen), Steiver. The Sox need a solid starter, but they need one on top of those guys, not in lieu.

There should be no "all-in" years from where the Sox are now. Every year for the foreseeable future should be a playoff team, with a chance to win (unless they decide to resume their 2014-16 clown show). The Sox had a losing record against playoff teams last year...playoff teams that went 1-12 in the playoffs. The Sox aren't 1 or 2 players away from being WS favorites (which is darn well where you need to be if you are going "all in").

Not it isn't. There is nothing that makes 2021 an "all in" year. And if Lynn is a top 5 pitcher in baseball (or even if he isn't, which he isn't) then sign him next year

Preach on, Steve.

1. No idea. 2. Prepare him to start; big waste of resources to do otherwise.

Because Marquez is a good pitcher in the prime of his career on a reasonable contract; they aren't squandering that to save Blackmon money. They can trade Marquez for, judging by what people hereon are willing to pay, high value. Then they salary dump Blackmon separately and pay 1/2 his contract or so; some team ... ahem .... ahem ....would probably give them a decent prospect...

Thanks for the analysis. If they are going to add some relievers, then they could go ahead and dump Cordero right now. And they should have moved one of those catchers in a trade before now. I'd like to see them keep those 2 pitchers that need protecting. Now that I think about it, it's less risky to leave a player off now and risk rule 5 than it is to add them to the 40 to protect against Rule 5, but then take them off later (where they would be on open waivers and not have to go onto the claiming team's 40 man). So there's no point in loading guys onto the 40 if you know you'll have to remove them later.................................................

It wouldn't.

The Sox have a defensive outfielder - one who actually hit last year.

Bummer is an elite set-up man. You don't need that kind of talent to pitch 1 clean inning. A closer just needs to be a good pitcher, with stones (Colome e.g.). Not sure of the fascination with Marquez; yes he's a good pitcher. I sense some wishcasting that he'll suddenly be elite once he leaves Colorado and the price appears to be set at that level. Doubtful. For a pitcher trade, I'd look at Musgrove. He has AL experience, he's been solid with Pittsburgh and his price would be very reasonable. Well it should be and if it isn't, then move on.

What we may be on the cusp of is having a playoff team for the next 5+ years. Don't mess that up by going "all in" especially for career years, convincing oneself that slightly above average players are somehow elite, etc.

Probably not. But has he ever been able to make moves without approval? I'm more worried about Hahn forced to make moves on the orders of LaRussa.

Trying to win and not overpay. Heck Kopech was the #2 for Sale; Kopech plus "good pieces" would approximate 75% of Sale's value (considering it was Sale, Kopech and not much else). Marquez isn't in Sale's area code.

Just wonderful.

You give Kopech and the like for a TOR pitcher, not Marquez.

In a front office; and after a couple of years, he may get another shot at GM. Just too many glitches in his resume, if you look under the covers. But, we'll see. If someone wants him as GM, I think he'll be gone.

They neutered him in the manager search, so I guess they demoted him de facto. I doubt any team would hire Hahn as their top guy: 1 organization experience, lackluster drafting and way too many unforced errors of the years.

If the Sox feel that way, then JR and Williams should fire him and bring in someone they trust.

I'm concerned about the goofy crap that this FO will do to fit the LaRussa 2 year window.

Stroman would probably be a capable rotation-filler. But we should also get that with another year of maturity from Cease and Dunning (although Stroman would be less risk). Nothing wrong with starting pitching depth- they'll probably wish/be glad they had it at some point in 2021.