Steve, I understand that he believes that what he decided to do was correct, but the whole process was arbitrary and allowed for loopholes where he could get out of not handing out a prize.
There was no true MVP award given for the games, so there was not a concrete result with the contest; it left it too open to debate.
I gave out prizes for the PTC of my own volition - there was a non-arbitrary way to decide the winner, so there was no argument as to who won.
SOXOBAMA, if you decide to continue your contest for the Super Bowl, might I suggest that you actually award a prize for the closest winner?