Im not getting the argument. You said that he looks "crappy" commenting on todays game and his statistics in the NL. He has been doing excellent this year and has much better stats than many other NL pitchers. Im not going to say that all pitchers will do great going from AL to NL (Barry Zito) because its just not true. I just dont see how you can say a player looks crappy when they are putting up great stats in their league.
Here is Peavy:
Era 3.97, 1.19 whip 92k's, 81.2 ip
There was a 100+ page thread about trading for him, notice every single one of those numbers is worse than Javy...
Im not saying Javy will continue, Im just wondering how you can call what he is doing "crappy".