1. Peyton Manning
2. Donovan McNabb
3. Michael Vick
4. Tom Brady
5. Daunte Culpepper
6-10 in no particular order
Drew Brees
Chad Pennington
Ben Roethlisberger
David Carr
Carson Palmer
i'm going to have tp disagree with you on this. Im a packer fan so of course im a huge Brett Favre fan. Peyton Manning, Donovan Mcnabb and Daunnte Culpepper are probably better than Favre now. But Tom Brady? Yeah he has the super bowl wins, but he is a product of a good system, put him on Dolphins and lets see how good he is. Drew Brees? The guy had one good year, he has been a average Qb all other years. Roethlisberger? Good rookie year, but he was super over hyped, he threw almost as many picks as he did tochdowns. David Carr and Carson Palmer have looked average at best, they every once in a while will look good but its way to early to start calling pro bowlers. Has Chad Pennington even played a full year yet? He has really weak arm and can't handle pressure.
I'm not even going to get into Mike Vick.