TaylorStSox

I think you move Rutherford up to AAA next year. He'll probably struggle in the first half again. Have him repeat AAA and look for a September call up in 21.

The key to all of it is going to be Madrigal. Will he be good enough to justify moving Moncada off of 2nd. I doubt there's a GM in baseball who would trade Moncada for Machado. Harper's a big can of whatever.

Eloy doesn't have the talent of Robert. He has a much longer swing and slower hands too. The reason it took Moncada longer to adjust is because he has such an advanced approach. I think Robert will be much more aggressive at the plate, but won't have the same strike zone mastery as Moncada. To use a White Sox comparison, Moncada is more Thomas and Robert is more Belle. I think Eloy is somewhere in the middle, but he's not nearly as physically gifted as the other two. Robert and Moncada are physical specimens with tools across the board. Regardless, Robert's timetable for adjustment has absolutely nothing to do with Moncada or Eloy or any other player that's played MLB.

You realize development isn't linear right?

I agree. Outside of the top 6, I think Rutherford is easily the most likely to stick on MLB team for years. Nothing really wows you, but he's good at pretty much everything. From the pitching side, I feel similarly about Pilkington. Again, nothing really wows you, but when I watch his videos and look at his make up, I see a guy that's going to have a nice career as a 4th/5th starter. There's a lot of value in that.

I mean, okay. I like Beane, but his influence outweighs his actual accomplishments. If we're talking about GM's that have built consistent winners, he shouldn't be included. That's all.

So, no? Exactly.

I've never really understood the entitlement of sports fans. The economy of sports isn't built on a barter system, it's built on entertainment. Either buy it or don't. It's like buying a ticket for a movie and asking for a refund if the movie sucks.

Yeah, but has Beane every actually built anything? How many rings? How many pennants?

Wouldn't the opposite be a 15 year run of injuries? That could be it.

I think he's a 2, but I also think he comps pretty well with Scherzer. I'm undecided, but at this point if you asked if I wanted him to start game 7 of the world series, I'd say no. So in that regard, he's not an ace. Also, Buehrle wasn't an ace. Out of all our pitchers, I think Kopech is the ace because he has the heaviest fastball.

Good thing we have a year to figure it out.

This post has been edited by the Soxtalk staff to remove objectionable material. Soxtalk encourages a free discussion between its members, but does not allow personal attacks, threats, graphic sexual material, nudity, or any other materials judged offensive by the Administrators and Moderators. Thank you.

He doesn't. People are weird.

Any time you can get value from a reliever when you're a non-contender, you take it. We have months to replace Colome, either externally or internally. One of Burdi, Hansen, Fulmer or Hamilton could emerge. If not, you have the entire off season to find relievers.

Moncada's eye gives him the edge, but it's a 1a and 1b situation.

The key is to not let the runner get in scoring position.

Your sig is broken.

I'm fine with that zone if both pitchers get it.

We're watching the evolution of one of the most advanced hitters you'll see.

I think it's Moncada, but Robert isn't far behind.

It's going to be interesting to see how he reacts to older pitchers with more control of their offspeed stuff. Can he lay off sliders that might not be as dynamic, but can be thrown for strikes more often? Regardless, there's gonna be some fastballs launched into next year.

no If you haven't figured it out by now, default = moan4yoan = tomplongo. You got to keep up with the trolling.

If it makes you feel better, Yoan4Moan is a Cubs fan troll who's been banned under other screen names. Jerry kicked Lip's dog in the 80's or something and he hasn't said anything positive on these boards since 2001. If you can actually make it through an entire Caulfield ramble, you might actually be crazy too. If you ignore those 3, the board starts making a lot more sense. Carry on.

This is such a weird take.