TaylorStSox

When young players are ready, it's no longer a rebuild, right? I just don't know how you "go cheap" on a rebuild when going cheap is kind of the point.

Wtf does this mean? As opposed to an expensive rebuild? ?

Four years later? Semien was a 3 WAR player his first year in Oakland. It was a dumb trade at the time and its still a dumb trade.

Cease has been real solid in AAA, but not exactly exceptional. There's no rush.

I'm on board with Bumgarner. The staff needs a vet and a lefty. He'd fill 2 holes.

Hold on, are you not a parody account? Haha. I seriously thought you were a greg775.

I thought that was your thing.

He's fast too. It's super premature to talk batting titles though.

Competing for batting titles? That's a stretch.

People just need to accept that he's not a fantasy player and he'll never have a pretty slashline. That doesn't mean he can't be an extremely valuable player. He has a couple of elite tools. I don't think it's worth a top 5 pick, but it is what it is.

Because most MLB managers still believe in sacrificing AB's to get runners over. I'd prefer Moncada never wastes an AB and he also has some bat control issues. Madrigal is a much better fit for that role. Moncada should be trying to get on base and drive the ball. That's why I like him leading off.

Moncada in the 2 hole is a waste of the team's best hitter.

Right on. I agree with that. I think he'll be an ideal situational hitter, whose slash line might not be impressive, but will help the team win. He's going to challenge the sabr guys.

Well, one is in A ball and the other is an MLB hitter who's still refining his approach and has been transparent about it. I'll be completely shocked if Madrigal ever draws more walks than Moncada.

Or I'd have Collins in the 3 hole and Eloy in the 5th.

1. Moncada - switch hitter who gets on base and can swipe bags 2. Madrigal - tailor made for the 2 hole 3. Eloy - situational hitter with power 4. Robert - ungodly power potential

I didn't like the pick and still don't, but I'm also not worried about him making it on an MLB roster.

Wasn't Sirotka part of that group too. He flamed out due to injury, but was good for a while and got us Wells.

He's 18. Just based on a few videos, his delivery looks pretty low effort. Maybe he can reach back when needed.

And Durham. See also: 2000

Well, Collins will be up this year and Burger had his leg amputated, so I'm not sure what you're expecting.

He's going to destroy baseballs regardless of how tightly they're wound. That sound off the bat is incredibly rare. I want to see him facing advanced pitching asap to find out who can exploit the holes in his approach. That's the next step in his development.

You left out Pilkington, Bush, Sheets, Walker and Rutherford. They're all still legit prospects.

If all things pan out, you're looking at a future rotation of Gio, Kopech, Cease, Vet FA, Reylo. Ideally, you'll have Dunning back in the mix in 2 years and Pilkington might behind that. I'll take it.

It was wise when it happened. WAR loved Eaton a lot more than reality. He was good when healthy, but he wasn't 3 big time prospect good.