QUOTE (TaylorStSox @ Apr 21, 2014 -> 08:23 AM)
Defensive stats are absolutely meaningless. The only good tool to judge defenders is your eyes.
I don't agree that they're "absolutely" meaningless, but like all stats they fail to take into account unquantifiable variables, like weather, field condition, the speed at which a ball is traveling, defensive positioning (good coaching) and minor injuries that probably contribute a lot more to defensive range than even a 3-year average statistic will ever be able to measure. Like you, I prefer the eye test when it comes to defense. But there must be some validity to UZR since it seems to be used more and more in professional evaluation.