Luke Appling?
Bench, Gehrig, Joe Morgan, Honus Wagner, Mike Schmidt, Williams, Mays, Ruth.
Walter Johnson, Lefty Grove, Cy Young, Warren Spahn, Bob Gibson.
Eckersly and Wilhelm in the Pen.
That was my White Sox bias coming out.
I'm cool with that. For what it's worth, Bill James lists Eddie Collins as the second best 2nd baseman of all time, behind Morgan.
After I posted my list, I remembered somebody named Barry Bonds, who really has to be on the list. I'd have to freeze out Ted.
Freeze out Ted Couldn't let that one go without comment...