I think we’ve had this discussion before if I’m not mistaken.
Offensively what he did last year I believe is what he is. It’s the defense that was greatly overrated. Between the errors, catcher interference, the lackadaisical plays (I remember when that relay home just went through his legs since he wasn’t looking/prepared), and pitch calling. I do not believe he is an above average defensive catcher despite what the metrics say about his framing.