Using ZiPS projections:
Lineup:
I had to move around some IP to get to 1420 total IP (accounting for some road losses).
Starters:
Adam Wainwright: 214 IP, 2.85 ERA = 68 runs
John Danks: 200 IP, 3.82 ERA = 85 runs
Ricky Nolasco: 188 IP, 3.78 ERA = 79 runs
Jake Westbrook: 183 IP, 4.11 ERA = 84
Tim Stauffer: 182 IP, 4.16 = 84 runs
Relievers:
Brad Bergesen: 100 IP, 5.09 ERA = 57 runs
Louis Coleman: 68 IP, 3.97 ERA = 30 runs
Alberto Arias: 55 IP, 4.12 ERA = 25 runs
Robinson Tejada: 59 IP, 3.66 ERA = 24 runs
J.P. Howell: 61 IP, 3.12 ERA = 21 runs
Matt Thornton: 59 IP, 2.91 ERA = 19 runs
Rafael Soriano: 53 IP, 2.91 ERA = 17 runs
593 earned runs allowed + 60 unearned runs = 653 runs allowed
Pythagorean win percentage: 60.9%
Pythagorean win record: 98-64
I was bored.