I don’t even know why it was looked at as an argument, no one said he wasn’t good. The merits of him being great though are still very questionable, now and in the future, that’s all the point was.
Ok, so what is he excellent or very, very good?
look he’s a good player and may be our best player for many years. He’s got a long way to go though. He’s hurt constantly, what’s that saying.. the best ability is availability
He can’t stay healthy and he has abysmal plate discipline, I’m not saying he’s not a good player but he’s so far from being great it’s not even debatable