QUOTE (Leonard Zelig @ Oct 29, 2011 -> 02:32 PM)
The Sox did not trade with St. Louis.
You are correct. This was 2 separate deals. First trade was between us and the Blue Jays. Second trade was between the Blue Jays and Cardinals.
For our trade:
Edwin Jackson (Type B FA) vs. Jason Frasor (Type B FA or 2012 club option) = Both can be offered arbitration for a similar draft pick, but KW can exercise the club option for Frasor and either keep him for another year, when he will probably be a Type B FA again, or deal him for immediate help. His club option at 3.75M will/should be easier to deal to a team instead of that team offering multi-year contracts to a free agent reliever. Sure, Frasor didn't perform as well as he should have in Chicago, but his history in the AL East speaks for itself and thus his salary is a bargain. Advantage: White Sox
Mark Teahen (5.5M 2012 guaranteed contract) vs. Zach Stewart (cost controlled pitcher) = Easy call here. Getting rid of the 5.5M and getting a pitcher who may or may not pan out is easily in our favor. Clear winner: White Sox
The White Sox also managed to save a few million, possibly 6 or 7, during the 2011 season.
So after breaking down this deal, we are clearly winners, unless Teahen magically turns into Albert Pujols, which is unlikely to occur.
Then after KW made this deal, the Blue Jays made a deal with the Cardinals, which we were not a part of. The deal broke down as Rasmus to Toronto for pitching (Jackson, Dotel, Scrabble) and Corey Patterson. The Cardinals excelled with all these players, while Rasmus is still searching for his breakout 2010 season, which may or may not have been a fluke. The Cardinals won the World Series with the help of these players in this deal.
So after looking this over, I come to the conclusion that the White Sox won their deal clearly and the Cardinals won their deal clearly. Rasmus may become something special, but no way St Louis win the World Series without this trade, where winning the World Series is the ultimate goal.