-
Posts
13,242 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
10
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by DirtySox
-
Just got to the White Sox section of the podcast. Nothing earth-shattering. - We've heard both hitting and pitching profiles linked to them (We sure haven't on this board). - Griffin is mentioned with the White Sox recently. - Have a gut feeling they would like Wetherholt to fall to them, but this seems less likely as of late. - Hard to see Jac falling further then this. - Assumes Condon/Bazanna don't get here. - Best guess is college bat. - Wonders if the success with Colson/Schultz (preps) pushes them towards Griffin. - Carlos opines that the risk level between Cags and Griffin aren't that different.
-
There just seems to be some glaring warts with both Jac and Griffin that I don't trust the White Sox to get the most out of. That's probably why I keep coming back to Wetherholt despite the injury issues.
-
In BA's draft podcast today they do a preview for all 30 teams. There is a sizable section at the start where they just talk about Jac Caglianone in general. It's very insightful. Paraphrased below. This is conversation between Carlos, Ben, and Peter. It all started with the question "Do you get a sense that Cags is a polarizing player?" I was slightly disappointed that they didn't talk about his defensive chops. Maybe that's telling though? I'm much more into Jac if he can be an average RF.
-
Interesting. Looks like he has them passing on Wetherholt in that mock. No longer an option? Or do they just have Jac higher you think?
-
7/10 Campfire Milkshakes vs. Twinkies Straight DH 1:10PM CT
DirtySox replied to DoUEvenShift's topic in 2024 Season in Review
The Maldy trade at the deadline is going to bring a HUGE return. -
7/10 Campfire Milkshakes vs. Twinkies Straight DH 1:10PM CT
DirtySox replied to DoUEvenShift's topic in 2024 Season in Review
Hahahaha -
7/10 Campfire Milkshakes vs. Twinkies Straight DH 1:10PM CT
DirtySox replied to DoUEvenShift's topic in 2024 Season in Review
Let's go! Do it again! -
7/10 Campfire Milkshakes vs. Twinkies Straight DH 1:10PM CT
DirtySox replied to DoUEvenShift's topic in 2024 Season in Review
RAWR! Let's go Luis! ? -
7/10 Campfire Milkshakes vs. Twinkies Straight DH 1:10PM CT
DirtySox replied to DoUEvenShift's topic in 2024 Season in Review
Fantastic bounceback after that first inning for Fedde. Gamer. -
Some cliff notes from this as I watch/listen. - Keith reiterates how bad of a draft class this is. Especially compared to last year's. Carlos says it's the worst he's covered. - Law really likes Condon. Comps him to Kris Bryant. - Carlos says BA would have Cags ranked lower then the industry due to the chase rate. Notes he would be a 3rd round talent as a pitcher. Says the defensive profile is polarizing. - Law says Cags power is unmatched in this class and that he should abandon pitching entirely. Says he would try him in RF with the 80 arm, and if it doesn't work move him back to 1B. Also notes the approach really needs to change on the chase rate. - Law has Burns/Smith neck and neck with Smith lower due to the previous TJ surgery. - Law is the high guy on Braden Montgomery. Carlos is worried about the contact skills. Thinks teams might abandon the switch hitting. - They all agree that after the top 10, the first round is going to be chaos due to the fall off in talent. - Someone asks why Kurtz has been falling. Carlos gets into how risky the 1B profile is. Mentions Jacob Berry, Andrew Vaughn etc. - Keith Law loves Ben Hess. Thinks he should be a 1st rounder. Surprised he's not ranked higher by others. - They all think Brecht will go in the first round. The stuff is ridiculous but the walk rate is still super scary. Probably a late 1st round guy. They mention the Dodgers picking him and having him fixed up in a hurry. (of course) - Asked about first player to the majors from the class. Mentions Kurtz, Yesavage, Chase Burns, Hagen Smith, Tibbs. - On comps: Bryce Rainer = Corey Seager. Konnor Griffin = Jo Adell. Bryce Rainer = Brice Turang. They all reiterate that they hate comps though.
-
BA draft roundtable coming up with Keith Law and Shooter Hunt. Should be a fun listen.
-
Fedde with a second incredible catch today.
-
7/10 Campfire Milkshakes vs. Twinkies Straight DH 1:10PM CT
DirtySox replied to DoUEvenShift's topic in 2024 Season in Review
Eder gonna eat some innings today for sure. -
Cost is a big deal because it gives you flexibility in how you spend your allotment. Save a million on your 1st round pick? Maybe you can now afford to push a better player down the board to spend that savings on with a later pick.
-
Fletcher has 2 singles today and made a fantastic diving catch in CF. Nastrini is also looking solid thus far. Me posting this will probably mean the wheels are about to fall off.
-
Kiley has a bull/bear case for the draft prospects in his rankings from yesterday. He does mention the bull case for Jac including "real defensive value at either RF or 1B." I would feel a lot better about the selection if that was a consensus.
-
Wetherholt, Griffin, Cags, in that order. If there was a consensus that Caglianone could provide some sort of defensive value in a corner OF spot, the calculus changes for me. But if he's 1B only I think I'd even prefer Braden Montgomery to him.
-
Just catching up. That 10 pitch at bat Colson had was fantastic. The result.
-
I'm just going to assume that if Bazzana falls, the Sox snap him up. Same with Condon.
-
GMs skeptical teams meet price for Robert
DirtySox replied to southsider2k5's topic in Trade Winds 2024
I really feel like the Phillies are perfect trade partners. Ballsy GM. Three different top 50 up the middle position players down on the farm. It makes too much sense. -
Kiley posted his final top 50. It says insider but is working for me as a non sub. https://www.espn.com/mlb/insider/story/_/id/40520082/2024-mlb-draft-rankings-30-top-250-prospects-final-condon-bazzana-caglianone
-
Thanks Jimmy. Oakie is a guy I've wanted since early on. Would be stoked.
-
Big George on the hot sheet again. https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/ranking-the-20-hottest-mlb-prospects-hot-sheet-7-9-24/
-
Me too bro.