Obviously it was over a decade ago and it took a while for Rodon to put it together, but I remember Rodon being the #1 and then the Astros and Marlins decided to drastically overthink it with Aiken and Kolek.
In recent memory, was looking up early-rankings from Pipeline. Putting the #1s actual draft spot then the actual #1's pre-season ranking
2019: Bobby Witt #2, Adley Rutschman #2
2020: Emerson Hancock #6, Spencer Torkelson #2
2021: #10 Kumar Rocker, Henry Davis (outside of Top 20)
2022: #5 Elijah Green, Jackson Holliday (outside of Top 20)
2023: #2 Dylan Crews, #4 Paul Skenes
2024: #2 Chase Burns, Travis Bazzana (outside of Top 20)
2025: #4 Ethan Holliday, #9 Eli Willits
But I feel like Roch has been hyped more than others except maybe Crews, back to the days of Stras and Harper (though NO ONE has had that hype)