He wasn't even that great last year.
He is sporting a -1.1 fWAR and -41 wRC! Think about that. He's done that poorly in so few at bats. He is so bad. I know you can't look at some things without rose colored glasses, but he's been that awful
President Martin Van Buren was nicknamed the little magician, so everybody bashing it can slow their roll. If it was fit for a president, it's fit for a baseball player
Jose is 17th is wOBA and 14th in wRC+. He's pretty middle of the pack as far as starting 1st basemen go. I don't think any team goes crazy and gives him more than 3y/36m, at most
https://chicago.suntimes.com/2019/2/19/18328665/team-player-jose-abreu-prepares-for-what-could-be-last-season-with-white-sox
"Abreu always has made clear his disdain for being the designated hitter"
The proof is in the pudding. There is a reason we kept seeing him at 1st while a better fielding Alonso was the DH. Abreu better settle into that DH role and accept it. His defense will only get worse.