ChiSox59

If the Sox RELEASED Castillo, he would have multiple MLB offers to chose from.

That Laz Rivera + Carson Fulmer for Joc Pederson deal would have been pretty solid, eh?

Still think we'll get 3 on this trip.

I've mentioned this elsewhere, but it is just insane to me that the Sox are unwilling to give Lambert or Flores a shot right now. They're both 25ish, and both are going to have a very tough time cracking into the rotation next year. Give them a shot now while the opportunities are there! I'd ultimately be fine with the Sox cutting Castillo, but I don't think they will. If they plan for Collins to DH even 50% of the time against RHP, we probably need to carry all three catchers. I think it actually makes a decent platoon. McCann C and Collins DH against RHP (Collins occasional C start). McCann C versus LHP and Welington DH (Castillo occasional C start). The odd man out in that scenario is obviously Alonso. IMO - that move should be made...like, today. Also trade out Mendick for Rondon. Cease will be up mid June, IMO.

This. There is no rush.

At least Gio has turned it around in a big way. If we were getting more 2018 Lucas things would be very grim.

There is a zero percent chance Alonso is on the roster next season.

Yah, the Sox aren't signed Rendon. They aren't moving Moncada off 3B. Its not happening. Get your hopes up on Cole if you want. There may be a shot there.

Cole would be a good start. Grandal would be nice. Several mid to back rotation guys that would fit on short term deals. Marcell Ozuna or Nick Castellanos in to shore up RF with Eloy and Robert. They could easily spent the $300M they would have had to give Machado next offseason. 95% chance they don't, but they could. And they'd probably be better off than they would have been with MM, even though I obviously really wanted him.

No

I dare ya to digress.

Yawn

Plenty of guys left to spend money on. Now the Sox actually doing it is another story.

Lol.

I think you'd be disappointed in what the current offer for Colome would be.

The team that would pick him up in this scenerio would be the team on the hook for the vesting option. And its actually only 526 PA based on how many he got in 2018. It would very clearly be Rondon that would go before Yolmer.

Look, I am not some big Castillo fan but he serves a purpose on the roster. Even with Collins up. Do you really call Collins up to be the back up catcher? If you're calling him up to be the DH against RHP, you're going to need a third catcher. McCann, Collins and Castillo can coexist just fine on the 25 man. The odd men out would be Alonso (please) and likely Palka too, unless you want to have an OF with Eloy and Palka in it. As I said earlier this thread, McCann and Collins cover DH and C against RHP. Castillos backs up. McCann and Castillo cover DH and C against LHP. Collins backs up. It makes a lot of sense, but it obviously does not work with Alonso on the roster.

You struggle with reading comprehension.

They are literally opposite platoon mates. Castillo should not play against RHP. Collins should not play again LHP. They can coexist on the roster just fine. Obviously Castillo is not a future piece. But he's also not a complete bum, and he will most certainly spend several more years in the big leagues. The Sox don't need to cut him him.

I think its a simple as Ricky is unable to fill out a lineups card that doesn't go righty/lefty/right/lefty. He is truly a pitiful manager.

I am with with most of this plan (I'd ultimately be OK with Happ for Colome, but would want more), but really don't see the need to trade Leury. He's not going to return much, but he's super useful. He's the perfect utility guy. I'd keep him around unless someone wants to overpay. I also don't think Castillo is getting released anytime soon. He is a legitimate MLBer. He's had a rough go with the Sox, but he's mashed LHP in his career, and I have no problem keep him on the roster. In fact, Castillo, McCann and Collins form a pretty decent 3-headed C/DH rotation in which McCann catches RHP and Collins DHs. Castillo and McCann split DH / C duties against LHP. Collins gets an occasional start at C against RHP.

At least Dunn could take a walk! Give me 2011 Adam Dunn over 2019 Alonso all day errrrday.

I just don't see how anyone can argue giving Alonso the DH at bats over Palka. If you want to argue Collins over Palka, that makes some sense I guess. But there is literally zero reason for the Sox to continue to run Alonso out there everyday. There isn't a chance in hell they're recouping anything worth a damn in a trade for him. Just cut him, let someone else sign him for the MLB min, and take your ~$400k or whatever in savings, and put someone who has at least a 1% chance of being a future piece in his place. I know they'll eventually do it, but just do it now.

Moncada and Kopech are most critical. Eloy and Cease for Q was easily the best return.

Yah, I'm aware. I live in Minneapolis and watch the Twins whenever the Sox aren't playing. He didn't become the second coming of Johan Santana over the offseason, new cutter be damned. I'd be surprised if he had an ERA below 4 by seasons end.