steveno89

I'm shocked so many are giving up on Collins after a few mlb games. He should be sent back to AAA to get regular at bats, but he could still turn out to be a solid player.

Reed is literally a zero risk move for the White Sox to test out at this point. I'm not sure how fans can view this as anything but a positive. If he sucks we can easily cut him, and if he's good well then great news. For Reed this is probably his final MLB opportunity to show he can stick, hopefully he makes the most of it.

The extension suggestions I see being thrown around online are crazy to me. Abreu is a quality veteran, but I am leery of extending him beyond another season or two. Sox hold leverage, as I do not think Abreu would get more than two years on the open market.

I agree that the extension numbers being thrown around are crazy for a half season of good production. Sox absolutely can be patient as McCann is still under arbitration control next season, plenty of time to evaluate.

Perfect storm would be Reed becomes JD Martinez 2.0 Small chance of it happening, but again this is a zero risk pick up

The more I think about it, the Sox very well might go down the qualifying offer road with Abreu. There just is not reason to go beyond a two year deal for around $25 million at this point. Paying retail for an aging slugger would be a mistake.

I love Abreu, but I do not think it would be wise to extend him beyond two more seasons. He does not walk much, and if the average dips much below .260 he becomes a near replacement level player. Hahn should hopefully be too smart to pay retail for an aging slugger. Abreu has value to this club, but I cannot get on board for anything beyond a two year offer, perhaps with a club option?

Not sure how it would be remotely feasible to trade McCann at this point. What other options for catcher do we have moving forward that would be even close to what he has given us so far in 2019? McCann is absolutely staying for 2020 at a minimum at this point. I doubt the Sox deal Abreu, especially since they are still somewhat in wild card contention. If they were going to deal him they would have already I feel. This move was a simple way to add depth. Reed was a former top prospect who might benefit from a change of scenery. If he does well I wouldn't rule out the Sox giving him some at bats in the majors down the stretch? If he sucks you cut bait, zero risk.

Sox fans wanted Martes + Tucker + Reed/Stubbs for Quintana. In retrospect we should be extremely happy we have Eloy/Cease instead. Tucker could still pan out, but Martes/Reed have little value right now.

Exactly^ This is in terms of fantasy, not necessarily real life. Madrigal would be considerably higher due to his above average defense at 2B. Vaughn likely starts out around #35 overall at MLB.com when the new rankings come out. The bat is for real and he could move quickly through the system.

A realistic expectation for a guy like Madrigal would be a batting average around .300, .350 OBP, plenty of doubles, 20+ steals, quality baserunning and excellent defense. While he might not have the 6+ WAR ceiling of certain prospects, I feel Madrigal can consistently become a 3-5 WAR player, a very valuable piece to have. The plus defense at second base could be worth 1-2 WAR on its own.

Sox should be looking to contend in 2020 given they are "around" .500 in 2019 already. They should absolutely be players in free agency as they look to fill holes. Robert and Madrigal should both be pushing for the majors by May/June next season at this rate. Kopech should be ready to go, Cease will be up.

A young player like Robert will benefit from getting more reps and facing a variety of pitchers in the minors. Major league pitching is a completely different animal. Everyone has solid stuff and can get you out in a variety of ways. Luis is obviously talented, but there is no reason to have him up at the major league level after 50 AA games on a team not competing for the postseason. I wouldn't mind him seeing time in Charlotte for the final month of the year though.

Is is just me, or does it seem like the Sox have their head up their a$$ by only being connected to Yolbert Sanchez and little Tatis? I was expecting more with two years to prepare?

Can't see the Sox moving McCann at this point since we really do not have much in the way of options outside of him within the organization beyond him. He has played well enough to consider extending.

I just scoured all of the current contenders' farm systems and it's not really easy to find a trade fit at first glance. Cubs don't have the farm to get it done realistically Tampa does have the farm, but they are so penny pinching I wonder if they would want to take on Colome's contract? Plus they already had and traded him in the past. Minnesota - Division rival, tough to get a deal done with when the Sox will likely try to start competing in 2020 Yankees - Thin farm system, I don't really see a prospect fit for the Sox here. Texas - Thin farm, unexpected contention. I don't think they are a great fit. Houston - Whitley/Tucker/Alvarez aren't going anywhere, and surprisingly their farm is not as deep as it has been in recent years. Milwaukee - Possibly, but I don't love the prospects at the top of their system. Kiura isn't being dealt and their depth drops off substantially from there. Philedelphia - rebuilding and I doubt they feel close enough to make a costly trade. Ditto for Washington, Colorado, San Diego

I highly doubt we would get a prospect of Waters' caliber, but you never know since the Braves are in contention

There is a saying that goes "always be trading relievers" and I absolutely think the Sox should listen to what they can get for Colome in a trade.

Agreed. Real contenders have a reliable bullpen that does not blow leads.

Sanchez is reported to have 65 grade defense at SS by MLB.com, which is nothing to scoff. If a player like that develops the hit tool to be adequate you are looking at a regular or a utility player at minimum.

Even halfway decent starting pitching is very expensive to trade for. Every MLB club could use starting pitching depth. Cease will be up by August, and I don'[t blame the Sox for not rushing him to the majors just yet.

Praying this is sarcasm like I think it is?

Frazier has supposedly been very poor defensively in RF this season. That has to be a consideration in addition the the Yankees outfield logjam. I could see them trading Frazier + for a starter

Sox don't have all that much to trade that I would consider expendable at this point. Robert, Cease, Madrigal, Vaughn, Kopech are not going anywhere Dunning, Adolfo are coming off injury Rutherford, Basabe, Gonzalez all have had poor 2019 performance

If Madrigal is not objectively better than Yolmer Sanchez RIGHT NOW, then we never should have selected him in the top 5. I'm not saying he's ready or to call him up yet, but if he couldn't better Yolmer's numbers I'd be pissed.