Tony
-
Posts
36,004 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
45
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Posts posted by Tony
-
-
Said it before, but I'd put together a deal that is 5 years, and significantly front loaded. Payroll is going to be at all time lows in 2025 (and probably 2026) so they have room in the budget. Absolute best case scenario is players develop over the next 24 months, and in 2028-2029 when the Sox have Schultz and Smith up at the ML level, Crochet is still pitching at a high level (he'll still be younger than 30) and at that point he's on the backend of the deal, affordable and still looking for his next big contract.
-
1
-
-
41 minutes ago, WestEddy said:
They left spring training a bad team, and losing what were supposed to be their top 3 hitters made them worse. The article clearly states this, as I have. We can agree that not being on course to set the all-time loss record would be significantly different from a 115 loss season.
We can? If they lost 115 games but Eloy-Moncada-Robert play full-ish seasons, this team somehow may be in worse shape than it is now. We have yet to see the results of what this historic season brings, but the hope is it finally tells them everything needs to change. I’ll believe it when I see it, and certainly not holding my breath, but if they lost 105-110 games this season, it’s probably business as usual in 2025 at 35th and Shields
-
46 minutes ago, Rowand44 said:
And you got to meet me through sports so I mean how could you not love them.
You seem like a lot of fun.
I thought about the trip we took about a half hour after I wrote that.
5 of us, from this board, met up in Cincinnati in 2006 to watch the Sox for the weekend. Was a great trip. Sports is what brought us there.
-
1
-
-
43 minutes ago, TaylorStSox said:
Being a sports fan is irrational and shouldn't be examined the way consumer brand loyalty is examined. There's no inherent ROI in being a sports fan. Sports fans are 45 year old men that pay $12 for a beer while wearing a $300 jersey with another man's name on the back, as if they're LARP'ing. It's an 8 year old kid balling over a loss that has literally no impact on their real life and whose outcome is completely beyond their control. Sports are stupid. As such, any expectation of a return is stupid.
This is wrong on a lot of levels.
- I have a closer relationship with my dad because of sports. It’s something we can always talk about with each other. I have many friends who aren’t as close with their fathers as I am, because they don’t seem to have a lot to talk about. I also have really good memories with him around 2005 and the Hawks Stanley Cup run.
- I’ve been in a fantasy football league with 11 guys I went to high school with. I probably wouldn’t be in contact with probably 8 of those guys at this point in my life, but the fantasy league keeps us in touch and the main reason we’ve kept it going all these years.
- I’ve won a good deal of money from said fantasy league, because I stay up on the NFL, so there literally is an ROI associated with that
- Sports are communal. When the Hawks went through their from 2010-2015, the city was buzzing, especially during the playoffs. It was awesome going to the bars to watch those games with a packed house and everyone invested. It also brings us together. The country is incredibly divided politically where everyone thinks the other side is the “enemy.” But when you’re the fan of the same team, that stuff goes away and you’re on the same side/team.
- The actual payoff to your team winning can’t be matched by much. The Blackhawks went through a huge sexual assault scandal and it turned me off of the team for a while. But the memories I have of celebrating those cup wins didn’t change. Same with the 2005 White Sox. It became clear over time that team had a horseshoe up its collective ass given their lack of success in future seasons, but that doesn’t change the way I celebrated with friends and family in 2005.
I could keep going, but yeah…you’re wrong
-
4
-
1
-
-
5 minutes ago, JoshPR said:
If you think about it this season has been a blessing in disguise to be honest..
ehhhhhhh, I wouldn't go that far. If it didn't impact Jerry at all (which none of us know at this point) then all it was just a historically bad season in a long line of very bad seasons for the White Sox.
-
2
-
-
2 hours ago, fathom said:
Also, Tony has killed this franchise so much. He needs to go away.
I'm sorry
-
2
-
10
-
2
-
-
20 minutes ago, Milkman delivers said:
So much for that whole “best situation a #1 QB has ever been in”.
They lose next week and it’s going to get UGLY around Halas
-
Absolutely nothing has gotten better in three weeks. And I know there are things working against him, but Caleb looks absolutely awful. I don’t see how this gets better quickly.
-
There isn’t a single thing he said in that article that isn’t incredibly easy to believe. Based on what we have all seen and heard, it all checks out. And we should all be furious this is how they have run things for this long.
-
5
-
1
-
-
10 minutes ago, Quin said:
James McCann, who has been not good outside of Chicago.
McCann is a good pull, you’re correct
-
15 minutes ago, nitetrain8601 said:
Excellent point. What most people haven't zoned in on yet was the way they coach players. Speaking in generalities, and never specifics.
It explains why someone like Kopech is a whole lot better the moment he changed franchises while hitters like Eloy and Robert got worse as their careers with our team have gone on.
And there are so many different examples over the years of guys moving on and those teams getting a better performance out of the player. Obviously some players (Eloy being a good example) seemingly is who he is and really hasn't done anything with Baltimore, but there are so many cases where it's clear the Sox just don't know what to do with a player.
Look at Jake Diekman last year. Sox acquire him in 2022, he put up a 7.04 ERA in 30 innings with the Sox split over two seasons. He goes to the Rays, and puts up a 2.18 ERA in 45 innings.
Soxtalk veterans remember the phrase that was used her back in the mid 2000's, "Coop will fix'em" which was sort of a joke, but was a reference to guys like Matt Thornton, a guy who couldn't quite figure it out in Seattle and it seemed to really come together with the Sox.
When was the last time the Sox signed someone from another organization and really unlocked something, or brought the best out of the player? Truly no one comes to mind, I'm sure I'm missing someone, but really can't think of anyone off the top of my head. But there is a list too long to type of guys who come here and get worse. Just sad
-
1
-
1
-
-
6 minutes ago, nitetrain8601 said:
On Baseball America's Hot Sheet, I think they did a phenomenal job discussing just how can a rebuild go the other day. The White Sox have the third worst fWAR for position players in the history of the game, only trailing the 79 Athletics (who had a 20 year old Rickey Henderson to look forward to) and the 76 Braves.
The one thing they do decent on the field is starting pitching, but since they have no hitting coming up, they haven't drafted anyone, no one internationally is coming and they have nothing in the minors so they will have to trade a lot of that pitching for hitters. It's sad to be honest.
And even if they do that, and trade some of the pitching for hitting...why should anyone believe they will develop those new players into quality ML players?
-
1
-
-
I can’t get over Ohtani. He’s so far and away the best player to ever play the sport, and we’re living right in the prime of it
-
3
-
-
2 minutes ago, Paulie4Pres said:
It isn't the age of the plane. It's the fact that it sucks and is worse than the rest of the league. Seriously. Eight first class seats?
99% of people understand the issue, there are a few dolts that are seemingly argue to argue.
-
5
-
-
7 minutes ago, Quin said:
I've repeatedly said that the 2020 core is racking up wins if they had a competent organization in charge of them.
I 100% believe that there are multiple guys that have totally different career trajectories on other teams. I cite Andrew Vaughn often. I really believe he was just wrecked by the White Sox.
-
6
-
-
1 hour ago, fathom said:
Or there’s the possibility that Hahn was a source for this article and wanted to come across as innocent of the franchise collapse.
37 minutes ago, Harold's Leg Lift said:My money is on Haber. He's such a weasel.
16 minutes ago, Balta1701 said:I don’t have it in front of me but I don’t remember seeing it stated that Haber refused to comment as they did with Hahn. Did they?
The article states "Hahn declined to comment on this story."
The article also states "Haber did not respond to interview requests."
In most cases, when stating "He declined to comment on this story" that implies he was not a part of the story, but was reached out to. In theory you could walk the line and still use him for background, but that starts to get into murky territory when it comes to journalistic integrity.
-
2
-
-
The coach/first class discussion isn’t even about “comfort”
It’s about the standard across the league. It’s the same for the analytics department, baseball ops, etc. Everything is done worse on the South Side than it is with 95% of the other teams in the league. Thats the point
-
11
-
3
-
3
-
-
I’ve posted this before, but worth repeating given the topic at hand.
I was told when the Sox interviewed Joe Espada before the 2023 season, he left the interview telling people “It’s 2023 but they operate like it’s 2003. I have no chance here.”He obviously was right.
-
5
-
1
-
-
The bad news: Nothing will change until Jerry dies
The really bad news: None of us know when that is, and even when he goes, it's going to take a while to clean everything up.
We have another decade of this, at least.
-
4
-
1
-
-
5 hours ago, bmags said:
It's stuff like that that still makes me think this will improve. I saw them play last year, they aren't this bad. There is some major miscommunication on blocking scheme and the sights need to be directly on chris morgan. I would imagine stuff like that that looks so bad could have wright assuming he's got backup with the rb, who instead is delaying out up the middle. They should be embarrassed, hope they come out ready to play. They are not this bad.
Except on the play Ace posted above, Wright literally never takes his eyes off of 55. It's clear that's his assignment, and his body language says the same thing. It seems like he anticipated 55 cutting in (which never happens) but that was incredibly poor effort/technique/everything.
Chris Morgan DOES deserve a very close looking at, especially considering us knowing he was promoted to run game coordinator, somewhat of a strength of the team last year with mostly the same O-Line, and it's been horrific this year...but the play specifically posted really shouldn't relate to coaching, that type of "effort" should NEVER happen, and that falls on the player.
-
-
2 hours ago, T R U said:
So were all over here having a meltdown on the Dolphins message board I post on and one of the posters made an excellent comment about the Dolphins GM that I think fits absolutely perfect with the White Sox situation.
"It's hard to blame Grier for one reason.
He didn't force himself into this position.
Someone hired him and someone refuses to acknowledge Grier has some serious liabilities. You can't fault Grier for taking a high level job if someone's going to give it to him.
The problem is above Grier's paygrade."It's true, but it also doesn't remove all guilt from Getz. Part of the job. He may be unqualified, and I can separate two different things. 1. He shouldn't be in this job and Jerry is the one that deserves heat & 2. Getz is still the one making decisions, and we can be upset with those decisions. We can be mad at both.
But I agree with the general principle that I don't blame Getz for accepting the job. That's not on him.
-
4 hours ago, Kyyle23 said:
It’s such a petty s%*# move by Dan, total unforced error. Be professional. he is the voice and big name of that station and he couldn’t act like a fucking adult for a five minute crosstalk because a guy on the other side works with some shitty people. Guess what Dan, North and McNeil also have some shitty takes and tweets in their history and you worked with them for years, and also DAN HIMSELF HAS BEEN SUSPENDED FOR SEXIST TWEETS.
for a guy who has a thing about telling people to be professional, he sure didn’t follow his own advice
It's also old school gate keeping. He doesn't like Barstool. Eddie didn't do anything to Bernstein, and the station he is employed by decided to bring Eddie in to co-host. He decided to act tough (while Eddie was on a remote btw and not in studio) and put him in an uncomfortable spot, for absolutely no reason other than he's an old cranky asshole. I can be a giant prick to people when I think it's deserved, but there is no way anyone can make a coherent argument that Eddie deserved any of that. Just a shitty thing to do, and quite frankly the heat Bernstein is getting is long overdue
-
2
-
-
Putting out a statement that includes the word “impressed” in any part of it negates everything else said.
-
9
-
2
-
1
-
1
-
The Mystery of Luis Robert
in Pale Hose Talk
Posted
This.
I absolutely think there is an element to him not giving 100% this year and being checked out in far too many PA's, but based on everything we know about the internals with the Sox, he simply hasn't been developed and coached properly, which plays a huge role in this.
Baseball has always been in a chess match between pitchers and hitters. Scouting reports evolve, pitchers change their approach to certain hitters, and the hitters then need to adjust, and round and round it goes. That requires a dedicated staff to help players make those adjustments, and I don't believe that's happening at a respectable level.