I would keep Hamilton and Sheets and drop Goodwin. Goodwin is a decent option as a pinch hitter on the road in the WS replacing pitchers. But Hamilton is more valuable because he can pinch run anytime and replace Vaughn in left in games we are protecting a lead at the end. Hamilton, Robert, and Engel to close games defensively in the field would be awesome. Of course it would be games where we had a two or three run lead. Goodwin is fine as a 4th OF but how often would he be used in the playoffs prior to the World Series if we are healthy?