Of course there are obvious flaws.. Back end of rotation, rotation depth, depth should we lose another big bad, major league catcher depth.. Of course there are flaws.. Just less flaws than other teams. This is still an AL contender.
Lets say vaugn is in LF and Collins at DH. In the 7th inning can we replace hamilton with collins and then switch the hamilton and Vaughn positions so the defense is there while keeping vaughns bat? Unsure of the DH rules.
We may be the 2nd best AL team still along with the Twins. The AL is bad. Our lineup is still Top 5 in AL, our Bullpen is #1, our big question is backend of rotation.
Lucroy without a doubt is a worse hitter than both. That's unquestioned. His catching is better. I think we need the bat now more than the defense with Eloy out. Gimme both bats.