Jump to content

COVID-19/Coronavirus thread


caulfield12

Recommended Posts

Why isn't more focus (by the media, politicians and the scientific community) being placed on the time frame within which an infected person remains contagious? Instead,the focus seems to be how to achieve herd immunity. That is a strategy with competing political ideologies about about how to achieve it.

If the general public could roughly follow  the testing plan that major league baseball has in place it is conceivable that we could, like our baseball teams, control the spread of the virus. Economical and timely testing and lab results would be critical. (perhaps the  saliva based test could work).

If one were to test positive they would know they should quarantine for the next week. That would effectively take the contagion off the streets, one infected person at a time. No herd immunity but at the same time, we would be effectively fighting the spread of the virus. That could also be augmented with social tracing, a voluntary system where those who test positive take it upon themselves to quarantine and notify those who they may have contacted during the time period that they were contagious.

So far a system like that has been working for major league baseball. Maybe that should be the example for our country to follow, not Sweden.

 

Edited by tray
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, tray said:

Why isn't more focus (by the media, politicians and the scientific community) being placed on the time frame within which an infected person remains contagious? Instead,the focus seems to be how to achieve herd immunity. That is a strategy with competing political ideologies about about how to achieve it.

If the general public could roughly follow  the testing plan that major league baseball has in place it is conceivable that we could, like our baseball teams, control the spread of the virus. Economical and timely testing and lab results would be critical. (perhaps the  saliva based test could work).

If one were to test positive they would know they should quarantine for the next week. That would effectively take the contagion off the streets, one infected person at a time. No herd immunity but at the same time, we would be effectively fighting the spread of the virus. That could also be augmented with social tracing, a voluntary system where those who test positive take it upon themselves to quarantine and notify those who they may have contacted during the time period that they were contagious.

So far a system like that has been working for major league baseball. Maybe that should be the example for our country to follow, not Sweden.

 

Baseball is testing 1000 players every 2 days at a cost of tens of millions of dollars. The US has been stuck at just over 600,000 tests a day for about 2-3 months and even had weeks where testing went down. There are 50 million kids in schools, testing them 2x a week would need 100 million tests a week when the country can do 3 million a week, and would cost in the billions per semester, and that’s just schools.

The outbreak in the US is simply too large to deal with our current testing rate.

I don’t think the press focuses on herd immunity, I think they focus too much on “living with it” and all these grand strategies to disinfect surfaces, when what the governor of Texas said in May in his talk to his donors about his evil plan still holds true. If you have increased person to person contact, in work or schools or businesses, transmission will increase in response. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, StrangeSox said:

 

Meanwhile, nearly 1/4 of all mailed prescriptions in Cook County have been delayed. Either this is deliberate sabotage of a vital government service for political reasons, or it's simply a staggering level of incompetence. Either way, it's putting people at risk.

What's this have to do with covid?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, StrangeSox said:

People are relying a lot on the mail for things right now thanks to COVID, including vital things like medication, as mentioned in my post.

Ha! let's just be honest strangesox, you wanted to steer the convo more towards politics with that USPS statement. call a spade a spade.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Balta1701 said:

Baseball is testing 1000 players every 2 days at a cost of tens of millions of dollars.

You missed the point which was * if * testing was economical ...like the saliva testing I mentioned  ( I could not readily find a link) that could be an effective strategy given the short window within which infected people are contagious. (appx 10 days as I understand it). Perhaps it will be easier and more cost effective to implement testing than to find an effective vaccine that provides long term (at least a year) immunity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, tray said:

You missed the point which was * if * testing was economical ...like the saliva testing I mentioned  ( I could not readily find a link) that could be an effective strategy given the short window within which infected people are contagious. (appx 10 days as I understand it). Perhaps it will be easier and more cost effective to implement testing than to find an effective vaccine that provides long term (at least a year) immunity.

saliva testing should be a really effective tool, but because we are relying on a bunch of individual actors to get it up and running and set policy around it I'm still in wait and see mode. A town like Champaign-Urbana is a good pilot for this, but if it's just a few offices in Chicago doing this it kinda defeats the point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, tray said:

Why isn't more focus (by the media, politicians and the scientific community) being placed on the time frame within which an infected person remains contagious? Instead,the focus seems to be how to achieve herd immunity. That is a strategy with competing political ideologies about about how to achieve it.

If the general public could roughly follow  the testing plan that major league baseball has in place it is conceivable that we could, like our baseball teams, control the spread of the virus. Economical and timely testing and lab results would be critical. (perhaps the  saliva based test could work).

If one were to test positive they would know they should quarantine for the next week. That would effectively take the contagion off the streets, one infected person at a time. No herd immunity but at the same time, we would be effectively fighting the spread of the virus. That could also be augmented with social tracing, a voluntary system where those who test positive take it upon themselves to quarantine and notify those who they may have contacted during the time period that they were contagious.

So far a system like that has been working for major league baseball. Maybe that should be the example for our country to follow, not Sweden.

 

It should have been and it should be on quick and massive testing turn around.  But the federal government doesn't want to invest the funds to make this happen. Again the rest of the world figured this out, but we can't. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, bmags said:

saliva testing should be a really effective tool, but because we are relying on a bunch of individual actors to get it up and running and set policy around it I'm still in wait and see mode. A town like Champaign-Urbana is a good pilot for this, but if it's just a few offices in Chicago doing this it kinda defeats the point.

UIUC now accounts for 1-2% of all testing in the entire country every day. 

https://news.illinois.edu/view/6367/1990170345

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, southsider2k5 said:

It should have been and it should be on quick and massive testing turn around.  But the federal government doesn't want to invest the funds to make this happen. Again the rest of the world figured this out, but we can't. 

No one else had to go to the strategy of testing their entire population twice a week because no one in the developed world failed at getting at least partial control during the lockdowns. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, StrangeSox said:

People are relying a lot on the mail for things right now thanks to COVID, including vital things like medication, as mentioned in my post.

If it counts, my health insurance forms seem to be lost in the mail after nearly 2 weeks, so I damn well better not get sick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...