Jump to content

Garret Anderson


BrandoFan

Recommended Posts

Wonder what effect this has on Maggs? These two guys are fairly similar players. Both corner outfielders, very similar numbers over their careers and currently. Anderson is a couple years older I guess, but seeing this deal for ~$12/year might make Maggs realize that he won't be getting $15/year. Could help our chances of us keeping Maggs or it could have no effect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Angels Payroll:

graph-up.jpg

They are one the right track.

 

It doesn't guarantee them jack squat this year, but they could easily win the World Series again.

 

Most importantly, they already won the battle -- they got their fans to care about the team again. Once Bonds retires, Beane's magic wears off and Dodgers continue their ineptitude, Angels might just become California's favorite Cinderella team.

 

If the play their chips right, they might become Atlanta Braves of the ALW.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wonder what effect this has on Maggs?  These two guys are fairly similar players.  Both corner outfielders, very similar numbers over their careers and currently.  Anderson is a couple years older I guess, but seeing this deal for ~$12/year might make Maggs realize that he won't be getting $15/year.  Could help our chances of us keeping Maggs or it could have no effect.

Here's my take:

 

1. Anderson, at this point, is a superior defensive player.

 

2. Anderson has probably hit as well as Maggs in the last 3 years -- less OPS but spectacular RISP/clutch numbers to make up for the difference -- last 2 season, Anderson has basically been baseball best clutch hitter. And he did it with guys like Spezio protecting him in the order. Andeson also had postseason success, so you know big-time pressure is no problem.

 

3. Maggs has been more consistent through-out the years, but then again, that's why he made 2, 3 times what Anderson made in that span, so it's moot.

 

4. Paying Anderson 12 Mill is not that bad since Angels' payroll is 105. Paying Maggs 15 Mill, even if he was worth that, is near impossible with a 60 Mill payroll.

 

5. Then again, a GREAT (read: career) year from Magglio this year would certainly go a long way toward changing some minds. If he shows awesome power and ability to lead the Sox to ALCS, then his value would probably jump.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anderson isn't worth anymore then Maggs is. So I think their two contracts will be pretty close. I could see Maggs getting an extra million or so. I also firmly disagree with Anderson being considered the better defensive player.

 

I watch almost as many Angel games as Sox games and without a doubt I'd take Ordonez over GA defensively. The one nice thing about GA is he can slide over to center, something I don't recommend us doing with Maggs (Although he could be alright out there).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anderson isn't worth anymore then Maggs is.  So I think their two contracts will be pretty close.  I could see Maggs getting an extra million or so.  I also firmly disagree with Anderson being considered the better defensive player.

 

I watch almost as many Angel games as Sox games and without a doubt I'd take Ordonez over GA defensively.  The one nice thing about GA is he can slide over to center, something I don't recommend us doing with Maggs (Although he could be alright out there).

No, Anderson isn't worth more than Maggs -- but the opposite is probably true is well. That was my point.

 

And Anderson is a Gold Glove-caliber LF'er while Maggs is only a hair-above average in right -- his range is not what it used to be IMO, and in the last couple of years, his arm has been pretty average/erratic. Plus, as you said, Anderson can play a tolerable CF.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...