Jump to content

Why not Halladay?


BrandoFan

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 55
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

There is always Seattle to trade with.  1-5 so far, losing money, not hitting at all, could be looking for some bats.  Pinero, Franklin, Garcia, Meche, Moyer (assuming his last two starts are not going to be repeated for the rest of the year!).

I'll take one of Pinero, Meche or Garcia. But, from what I know, Garcia is the only one they'd be willing to part with. And what would the Sox ship as far as hitting? With the way Konerko is going, I want him to at least finish out the year here. Joe Borchard and others? Maybe?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

J.P Riccardi is the best GM in the businesss in my opinion, he's buildin the Blue Jays around pitchin. There's no way he's goin to trade their ace pitcher afta he just signed a long term deal. Delgado is prob walkin. afta the season so if any1's goin to get traded it will most likely be him. If we are loookin to trade for sum1 from Toronto, it should be one of their young stud prospects like Aaron Hill.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's no way he's goin to trade their ace pitcher afta he just signed a long term deal

 

Let's get real here: Halladay isn't exactly cheap long-term AND the market no longer rewards pitchers like Apprier with 13 Mill contracts,

 

It's not like I am asking for Vernon Wells here.

 

Will he do it for Pacheco, Diaz AND Wing?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's get real here:  Hallday isn't exactly cheap long-term AND the market no longer rewards pitchers like Apprier with 13 Mill contracts,

 

It's like I am asking for Vernon Wells here.   

 

Will he do it for Pacheco, Diaz AND Wing?

He won't get traded in the 1st year of his long term deal. We're not talkin about a Mike Hampton type of situation here where Halladay just can't pitch at all. He started out slow last year, like he's doin this season, and he still won the AL Cy Young. If Toronto wants to remain competitive in that division for the next 5 years while they wait for their prospects to get used to the big leagues, then they hav to keep Halladay. Talkin bout pitchers from Seattle, I'd say if they are out of the hunt, they'll want to trade Jamie Moyer, not Gil Meche or Joel Pineiro. And Riccardi would want a Kris Honel type of pitching prospect if he would trade Halladay.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is it about 4th place that says "competitive"?

Brando, It's f***ING april...

 

where the team with the best record is a game over .500 -- If teams gave up because of April, last year the marlins wouldn't have won the WS, the Twins wouldn't have made teh playoffs, we wouldn't have made those move in early July. --By your logic, I guess the yankees should pack it in too.

 

I realize you're bored and need to construct some false conflict through dumb trade ideas, but do something constructive. Do something enriching. Do something FUN... Go do your taxes or something..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Brando, It's f***ING april...

 

where the team with the best record is a game over .500 -- If teams gave up because of April, last year the marlins wouldn't have won the WS, the Twins wouldn't have made teh playoffs, we wouldn't have made those move in early July. --By your logic, I guess the yankees should pack it in too. 

 

I realize you're bored and need to construct some false conflict through dumb trade ideas, but do something constructive.  Do something enriching.  Do something FUN...  Go do your taxes or something..

Using this logic we should get Millwood.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Using this logic we should get Millwood.

Don't want him even if he was available.

 

Nor is Phillies' situation in ANY way comparable to that of Blu Jz -- NLE is wide open while ALE is NOT.

 

And for the record....I didn't mean dealing for him in April. More like early June, before the rest have a chance to bid.

 

Personal attacks notwithstanding, Toronto Blue Jays will have as much chance to compete with Yankees, Carmines and O's 2 months from now as they do today.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How about if Sox throw in Yofu and Mcarthy as well?

Brando, do you understand that this is not a video game? Not one of the pitchers you named is really a top notch prospect, all are quality prospects, but none of them really stand out (that doesnt mean that they won't in time).

 

In this dream scenario of yours, if we wanted to get Halladay - we'd have to trade at least one of the following, probably a few of these guys: Reed, Sweeney, Anderson, Honel, and to a lesser extent Borchard and Rauch.

 

No thanks to that....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In this dream scenario of yours, if we wanted to get Halladay - we'd have to trade at least one of the following, probably a few of these guys: Reed, Sweeney, Anderson, Honel, and to a lesser extent Borchard and Rauch.

 

No thanks to that....

 

Actially, I wouldn't mind giving up Anderson, Pacheco and Rauch/Borch.

 

If you think a 42/4 pitcher on a team that can't really afford him and won't finish higher than 3rd is worth Cotts, Honel, Reed, I got news for you: he isn't.

 

.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...