Player grades

[southsider2k5]

Shingo has double D's eh?  

 

I edited, but that is a great response

[Balta1701]

Buehrle doesn't deserve an A.

 

Buehrle has pitched 2 of the best starts in the AL all season - opening day against Cleveland and the 1 hour race against Seattle. Those 2 have to count for something.

 

And his loss to Minnesota happened as much because of an error by Dye as anything Buehrle did.

[rangercal]

Luis Vizcaino B (not gonna penalize him for the Clev. game)

 

Agreed. Based on numbers on paper , he would get a D- F. He definately took one for the team that day.

[T R U]

Buehrle has pitched 2 of the best starts in the AL all season - opening day against Cleveland and the 1 hour race against Seattle.  Those 2 have to count for something.

 

And his loss to Minnesota happened as much because of an error by Dye as anything Buehrle did.

 

I dont think Buehrle deserves an A either.. he has had some good starts but the ERA is still 4, and comeback wins have helped.. Thats why I thought my B+ for him was fair

[southsider2k5]

Buehrle has pitched 2 of the best starts in the AL all season - opening day against Cleveland and the 1 hour race against Seattle.  Those 2 have to count for something.

 

And his loss to Minnesota happened as much because of an error by Dye as anything Buehrle did.

 

He also gave up 7 runs to a mediocre Oakland team, and 3 homers to a horrible Royals team. With the expectations of MB being a Cy Young contender every years, I don't see how anyone could grade him higher than a C.

[AddisonStSox]

The Good

 

-Garland

-Iguchi

-Hermanson

-Widger

-Everett

 

The Bad

 

-Konerko

-Rowand

-Takatsu

 

The Ugly

 

-Dye

-Cotts

-Harris

[T R U]

And his loss to Minnesota happened as much because of an error by Dye as anything Buehrle did.

 

the "error" (It wasnt really an error but Joe was faulted by most) didnt cause Buehrle to get down 3-1 to Hunter and throw a fastball down the middle resulting in the 3 Run HR..

 

It can work both ways

[southsider2k5]

The Good

 

-Garland

-Iguchi

-Hermanson

-Widger

-Everett

 

The Bad

 

-Konerko

-Rowand

-Takatsu

 

The Ugly

 

-Dye

-Cotts

 

The MVP's

-Harris

 

There ya go Addy, I cleaned that up to show what you really meant.

[T R U]

There ya go Addy,  I cleaned that up to show what you really meant. 

 

[AddisonStSox]

There ya go Addy,  I cleaned that up to show what you really meant. 

 

 

You literally have me laughing out loud at my desk.

[WilliamTell]

Carl Everett A-

Paul Konerko D+

Ross Gload C

Willie Harris C+

Tadahito Iguchi A

Juan Uribe B

Joe Crede B

A.J. Pierzinski C+

Chris Widger B-

Scott Podsednik B-

Aaron Rowand D-

Jermaine Dye F

Timo Perez C-

Pablo Ozuna C+

 

Mark Buerhle A

Freddy Garcia A-

Jose Contreras A-

Orlando Hernandez A-

Jon Garland A+

 

Cliff Polite B

Neal Cotts C

Luis Vizcaino B

Damaso Marte C-

Dustin Hermanson A

Shingo Takatsu C-

 

That's mine, if I get hammered or whatever I don't care. I didn't put a lot of thought into it.

Edited May 4, 2005 by WilliamTell

[shawnhillegas]

Carl Everett A-

Paul Konerko C-

Ross Gload C

Willie Harris B

Tadahito Iguchi A+

Juan Uribe B-

Joe Crede B+

A.J. Pierzinski C

Chris widger B+

Scott Podsednik B-

Aaron Rowand C-

Jermaine Dye D

Timo Perez C-

Pablo Ozuna C

 

Mark Buerhle B

Freddy Garcia A-

Jose Contreras A

Orlando Hernandez A-

Jon Garland A+

 

Cliff Polite A

Neal Cotts C

Luis Vizcaino B

Damaso Marte B

Dustin Hermanson A+

Shingo Takatsu C

 

 

i still think contreras has been our 2nd most important pitcher this year.....i expected el duque to be alright but there was that chance that contreras would put up a 6 era ...... so far so good though and hes shown flashes of being a dominant pitcher

[bjm676]

Carl Everett A- (never put him on the field, that's why he has the -)

Paul Konerko D

Ross Gload Incomplete

Willie Harris C

Tadahito Iguchi A+

Juan Uribe B

Joe Crede B

A.J. Pierzinski Hitting: C Pitching Handling: A+

Chris Widger See Above

Scott Podsednik B (love how he runs the bases)

Aaron Rowand D

Jermaine Dye F

Timo Perez D

Pablo Ozuna Incomplete

 

Mark Buerhle B (Any pitcher who gives up 3 HRs to KC deserves a lower grade, but he'll improve)

Freddy Garcia A

Jose Contreras A- (Needs to cut down on walks)

Orlando Hernandez A- (See above comment)

Jon Garland A+

 

Cliff Politte A (Has been lights out so far)

Neal Cotts B

Luis Vizcaino C

Damaso Marte A

Dustin Hermanson A+

Shingo Takatsu D (Seems to be improving)

 

Ozzie B

[Allsox]

CODE

Carl Everett B (Great RBI count and Twins' killa!)

Paul Konerko C+ (Hitting the ball hard, just not finding the holes YET)

Ross Gload INC (Not enuff games)

Willie Harris C+ (Doing well in limited role so far and played decent SS)

Tadahito Iguchi B+ (Adjusting well to America, just needs to hop turning a DP)

Juan Uribe B- (Rock solid defense, needs to have better batting eye)

Joe Crede C (Rock solid defense, needs to maintain a consistent swing)

A.J. Pierzinski B (Great signal caller and a tough out)

Chris widger B (Also good signal caller and a tough out as well)

Scott Podsednik B (Defense solid and getting OB consistently, needs to drive ball in gaps for more doubles and triples)

Aaron Rowand C (Good D, finding his way to RF, which will lead to higher AVG)

Jermaine Dye D (Defense disappointing along with bat, sit out when Frank comes back)

Timo Perez B (Solid late inning replacement and a Twins' Killa)

Pablo Ozuna B (Has provided clutch hits and gives bench more speed)

 

Mark Buerhle B+ (Innings eater and keeps defense in game, needs to make better pitches when count is in his favor)

Freddy Garcia B (Rock solid, needs to throw fastball more to set up breaking stuff)

Jose Contreras C+ (Same as Garcia, throw fastball more to set up that devastating splitter)

Orlando Hernandez B (Gets into jams but gets outta them)

Jon Garland A (Unbelievable, has mixed Buehrle's pace with El Duque's moxie)

 

Cliff Polite B (Solid so far)

Neal Cotts C (Needs to throw Strike 1 more)

Luis Vizcaino C (Like Garcia, throw fastball more to set up good breaking stuff)

Damaso Marte B+ (So far, so good)

Dustin Hermanson A (Tough gritty durable worker)

Shingo Takatsu C (Needs to throw Strike 1 or the Sox are in deep s*** in 9th)

Edited May 4, 2005 by Allsox

[Princess Dye]

Carl Everett A

Paul Konerko C

Tadahito Iguchi A+

Juan Uribe B

Joe Crede A-

A.J. Pierzinski B

Chris widger B+

Scott Podsednik A-

Aaron Rowand C

Jermaine Dye D

 

Pablo Ozuna A-

 

Mark Buerhle B+

Freddy Garcia B

Jose Contreras B+

Orlando Hernandez B+

Jon Garland A+

 

Cliff Polite A

Neal Cotts B+

Luis Vizcaino B-

Damaso Marte A

Dustin Hermanson A+

Shingo Takatsu D

Edited May 4, 2005 by Princess Dye

[AngelasDaddy0427]

Here are mine...

 

Carl Everett - B-

Paul Konerko - D+

Ross Gload - D

Willie Harris - C+ (limited sample though)

Tadahito Iguchi - A

Juan Uribe - C+

Joe Crede - B+

A.J. Pierzinski - B-

Chris widger - B

Scott Podsednik - B+

Aaron Rowand - C- (only because he's just now started to get hot)

Jermaine Dye - F- (and I really want to give him an F - -)

Timo Perez - B-

Pablo Ozuna - C +

 

Mark Buerhle - C- (only because he's so not Buherle like)

Freddy Garcia - B - (I expect better)

Jose Contreras - B+ (Exceeding my expectations)

Orlando Hernandez - D+ (Heart attack Hernandez's luck will run out, lets hope he wises up and stops having his tee ball stand moments)

Jon Garland - A +

 

Cliff Polite - B +

Neal Cotts - D+

Luis Vizcaino - B-

Damaso Marte B-

Dustin Hermanson B-

Shingo Takatsu - C+

[Princess Dye]

why the really low grades for Cotts? i mean, a C i could understand.... but he's your second best lefty, so i dont know what you exactly expect from that slot

 

he's better than a lot of the Felix Heredias (Gah) that are just barely hanging around in this league.

[retro1983hat]

Carl Everett B

Paul Konerko D

Ross Gload Incomplete

Willie Harris C

Tadahito Iguchi A

Juan Uribe B-

Joe Crede B-

A.J. Pierzinski C

Chris widger B

Scott Podsednik C+

Aaron Rowand D

Jermaine Dye D-

Timo Perez C-

Pablo Ozuna C

 

Mark Buerhle B+

Freddy Garcia B+

Jose Contreras B-

Orlando Hernandez A-

Jon Garland A+

 

Cliff Polite B

Neal Cotts C

Luis Vizcaino C

Damaso Marte B

Dustin Hermanson A

Shingo Takatsu D+

[3E8]

Timo = A++

 

/end thread

[ChWRoCk2]

Carl Everett B+ (hitting well but not consistent0

Paul Konerko C (not hitting but has fielded well)

Ross Gload C- (doesnt play)

Willie Harris C (doesnt play but still is decent)

Tadahito Iguchi A (has hit well and fielded well, amazing player so far)

Juan Uribe B (cant give him higher since injury)

Joe Crede B (after streak hes cooled down)

A.J. Pierzinski B+ (pitchers work well with him and throw better)

Chris widger C (has been a good backup catcher)

Scott Podsednik C+ (many steals but needs a higher avg)

Aaron Rowand B- (not hitting as well as I hoped)

Jermaine Dye C+ (same as rowand comment)

Timo Perez C+ (hit well when no runners are on base)

Pablo Ozuna B- (been good so far)

 

Mark Buerhle B+ (needs to slow down hes rushing)

Freddy Garcia B (not impressing me with his control)

Jose Contreras C+ (hasnt got a win yet)

Orlando Hernandez B- (allows to many base runners)

Jon Garland A (nothing more to say than cy young)

 

Cliff Polite B (solid out of the pen)

Neal Cotts B- (i worry about him, doesnt have many pitches)

Luis Vizcaino B (needs to be more effective)

Damaso Marte B (dissapointing start)

Dustin Hermanson A (flawless, should be the closer)

Shingo Takatsu B (starting to improve to last years stats)

[BobDylan]

Buehrle - B

[BobDylan]

Mark Buerhle B+ (needs to slow down hes rushing)

Freddy Garcia B (not impressing me with his control)

Jose Contreras C+ (hasnt got a win yet)

Orlando Hernandez B- (allows to many base runners)

Jon Garland A (nothing more to say than cy young)

 

Jesus, nobody is perfect.

[CaliSoxFanViaSWside]

why the really low grades for Cotts?  i mean, a C i could understand.... but he's your second best lefty, so i dont know what you exactly expect from that slot

 

he's better than a lot of the Felix Heredias (Gah) that are just barely hanging around in this league.

 

He's a lot prettier too but I'm sure that doesnt influence at all.

[Be Good]

Jesus, nobody is perfect.

Garland's gotta be A+, unless you we're expecting him to do this than an A. But I dont think anyone was.

[Be Good]

MY GRADES: notice I didnt use any + or -

 

Carl Everett B

Paul Konerko C

Ross Gload C

Willie Harris B

Tadahito Iguchi A

Juan Uribe B

Joe Crede A

A.J. Pierzinski C

Chris widger C

Scott Podsednik B

Aaron Rowand D

Jermaine Dye F

Timo Perez F

Pablo Ozuna C

 

Mark Buerhle A

Freddy Garcia A

Jose Contreras A

Orlando Hernandez A

Jon Garland A

 

Cliff Polite A

Neal Cotts C

Luis Vizcaino B

Damaso Marte B

Dustin Hermanson A

Shingo Takatsu C