SoxFan1 Posted July 29, 2005 Share Posted July 29, 2005 QUOTE(AirScott @ Jul 28, 2005 -> 08:27 PM) I'd say Jeter really is overrated, simply because he has a .313 career average, 1,852 hits, 4 World Series rings, is only 31 and has been called overrated many times, despite all of that. as for most underrated, Rafael Palmeiro, his numbers are unbelievable, and the way it sounds, he only has a 50/50 chance of making the Hall. You seem to have them mixed up. I fixed that for you... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Harry Chappas Posted July 29, 2005 Share Posted July 29, 2005 (edited) Foxx Raffy if he is 50/50 Frank Thomas is out. The amazing thing about baseball is that in its history Yankee (or NY in general) players are so grossly overrated it is disgusting. Yogi Berra v. Mel Ott for instance (not sure about the stats but they are close) Whitey Ford Hell even Joe Dimaggio. His hit streak is nice but in the grand scheme of things what did it get him (what was his average during the streak). I'll take 3 2 for 4's and an 0 for 2 over three 1 for 4's and a 2 for 4. Hank Aaron was probably the greatest (behind Ruth) and you would think he couldn't hold Willie Mays jock with accolades draped on Mays (not saying he wasn't great). The media overhypes flair, pizzazz (not Piazza) and locale rather than real talent and achievement. I bet Jorge Posada is more of a HOF lock then Frank Thomas, christ there were stories on if Mattingly should make it. Harold Baines will pass on the balloting like Andre Dawson, too bad he didn't play longer with the cub he (Dawson) would've been a first ballot guy. With the Trib coverage of Sandberg this week (back page every day) did they do this for Fisk???You would have think he saved 10,000 children in a burning orphanage and then found them all nice warm homes. Enough of my rant, off to the USA radio poll to post the Trib comments on this, they are precious. Edited July 29, 2005 by HSC's Biggest Fan Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
White Sox Josh Posted July 29, 2005 Author Share Posted July 29, 2005 QUOTE(HSC's Biggest Fan @ Jul 29, 2005 -> 08:41 AM) Foxx Raffy if he is 50/50 Frank Thomas is out. The amazing thing about baseball is that in its history Yankee (or NY in general) players are so grossly overrated it is disgusting. Yogi Berra v. Mel Ott for instance (not sure about the stats but they are close) Whitey Ford Hell even Joe Dimaggio. His hit streak is nice but in the grand scheme of things what did it get him (what was his average during the streak). I'll take 3 2 for 4's and an 0 for 2 over three 1 for 4's and a 2 for 4. Hank Aaron was probably the greatest (behind Ruth) and you would think he couldn't hold Willie Mays jock with accolades draped on Mays (not saying he wasn't great). The media overhypes flair, pizzazz (not Piazza) and locale rather than real talent and achievement. I bet Jorge Posada is more of a HOF lock then Frank Thomas, christ there were stories on if Mattingly should make it. Harold Baines will pass on the balloting like Andre Dawson, too bad he didn't play longer with the cub he (Dawson) would've been a first ballot guy. With the Trib coverage of Sandberg this week (back page every day) did they do this for Fisk???You would have think he saved 10,000 children in a burning orphanage and then found them all nice warm homes. Enough of my rant, off to the USA radio poll to post the Trib comments on this, they are precious. Harold Baines has more hits than Ted Williams in his career. I know he isn't better than him however he would've had 3,000 hits had he not played in 2 strike years. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Al Lopez Ghost (old) Posted July 29, 2005 Share Posted July 29, 2005 QUOTE(White Sox Josh @ Jul 29, 2005 -> 08:11 AM) Harold Baines has more hits than Ted Williams in his career. I know he isn't better than him however he would've had 3,000 hits had he not played in 2 strike years. OK, but as I said, TW missed 4 years in military service, so take that into consideration. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
White Sox Josh Posted July 29, 2005 Author Share Posted July 29, 2005 QUOTE(Al Lopez's Ghost @ Jul 29, 2005 -> 09:59 AM) OK, but as I said, TW missed 4 years in military service, so take that into consideration. no i know and he was obviously not a better hitter than Ted, however Harolds total numbers are good enough to be in the HOF. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Critic Posted July 29, 2005 Share Posted July 29, 2005 QUOTE(Al Lopez's Ghost @ Jul 28, 2005 -> 10:05 AM) I'd mention Ted Williams. 521 ( I think ) homers and lost 4 years in his prime as a combat pilot fighting for his country. How can a guy who many many people call The Greatest Hitter Who Ever Lived be underrated? Was he the Greaterest? The Most Greatest? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SHAFTR Posted July 31, 2005 Share Posted July 31, 2005 Half the guys that have been mentioned are true legends. Guys that nearly everyone considers to be one of the greatest players of all time. I have one for you guys... Darrell Evans 3b, 1969 - 1989 Match his #s to Tony Perez and you'll see how underrated Evans is. His 162 game average .248 avg .361 obp .431 slug 25 HRs 82 RBIs Career OPS+ of 119 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ZoomSlowik Posted August 1, 2005 Share Posted August 1, 2005 (edited) QUOTE(HSC's Biggest Fan @ Jul 29, 2005 -> 08:41 AM) Foxx Raffy if he is 50/50 Frank Thomas is out. The amazing thing about baseball is that in its history Yankee (or NY in general) players are so grossly overrated it is disgusting. Yogi Berra v. Mel Ott for instance (not sure about the stats but they are close) Whitey Ford Hell even Joe Dimaggio. His hit streak is nice but in the grand scheme of things what did it get him (what was his average during the streak). I'll take 3 2 for 4's and an 0 for 2 over three 1 for 4's and a 2 for 4. Hank Aaron was probably the greatest (behind Ruth) and you would think he couldn't hold Willie Mays jock with accolades draped on Mays (not saying he wasn't great). The media overhypes flair, pizzazz (not Piazza) and locale rather than real talent and achievement. I bet Jorge Posada is more of a HOF lock then Frank Thomas, christ there were stories on if Mattingly should make it. Harold Baines will pass on the balloting like Andre Dawson, too bad he didn't play longer with the cub he (Dawson) would've been a first ballot guy. With the Trib coverage of Sandberg this week (back page every day) did they do this for Fisk???You would have think he saved 10,000 children in a burning orphanage and then found them all nice warm homes. Enough of my rant, off to the USA radio poll to post the Trib comments on this, they are precious. Berra- 19 seasons .285 career average, 358 homers, 1430 RBI Ott- 22 seasons .304, 511, 1860 I'm not sure what the point of that comparison is though since one was a catcher and the other was an outfielder. And since you brought it up... DiMaggion- 13 seasons .325, 361, 1537 Those are pretty impressive numbers considering how relatively few years he played. I'm not sure what you have against Ford either, he has a career ERA of 2.74 and led the entire league in ERA twice. As for Aaron/Mays, I'd say they were pretty similar at the plate. Aaron's numbers were slightly better, but Mays also played most of his career in some horrendous hitter's parks. When you consider that Mays was a slightly better runner and probably the best defensive OF ever, that's why he gets a ton of credit. In some cases, your team matters (cough, Phil Rizzuto, cough), but most of the time if you were really good you're in the hall. I can only think of a handful of guys that I think belong that aren't in, and several are closers, who seem to be undervalued in the hall. Edited August 1, 2005 by ZoomSlowik Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
knightni Posted August 1, 2005 Share Posted August 1, 2005 Hmm.. Joe D put up the same #s in 13 yrs that Yogi did in 19. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hammerhead johnson Posted August 1, 2005 Share Posted August 1, 2005 QUOTE(HSC's Biggest Fan @ Jul 29, 2005 -> 01:41 PM) Hell even Joe Dimaggio. His hit streak is nice but in the grand scheme of things what did it get him (what was his average during the streak). I'll take 3 2 for 4's and an 0 for 2 over three 1 for 4's and a 2 for 4. Joe DiMaggio is one of the most insanely talented players in baseball history. 361 homers to 369 strikeouts in his career? One of the greatest defensive outfielders of all time? 56 game hitting streak? The guy was absolutely superb. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SouthsideNorthsideFan Posted August 2, 2005 Share Posted August 2, 2005 QUOTE(The Critic @ Jul 24, 2005 -> 11:49 PM) I'll go with Hank Aaron. He was so much more than a home-run hitter, and IMO he goes underappreciated. underappreciated by whom, soccer fans?? LOL...I can't believe I just read that HANK AARON is underappreciated! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SouthsideNorthsideFan Posted August 2, 2005 Share Posted August 2, 2005 QUOTE(White Sox Josh @ Jul 29, 2005 -> 09:11 AM) Harold Baines has more hits than Ted Williams in his career. lol... QUOTE(knightni @ Aug 1, 2005 -> 01:13 AM) Hmm.. Joe D put up the same #s in 13 yrs that Yogi did in 19. Yogi, catcher. I doubt Joe D threw out or called anywhere near as many as Yogi. Nice apples to oranges comparison. Hey...is the love for Raffy still rampant after today's news? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SouthsideNorthsideFan Posted August 2, 2005 Share Posted August 2, 2005 I failed to add: Rock Raines. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
knightni Posted August 2, 2005 Share Posted August 2, 2005 QUOTE(SouthsideNorthsideFan @ Aug 1, 2005 -> 10:23 PM) lol... Yogi, catcher. I doubt Joe D threw out or called anywhere near as many as Yogi. Nice apples to oranges comparison. Hey...is the love for Raffy still rampant after today's news? It was only an observation. PS, if you were a real Sox fan, you'd hate that avatar of yours as much as I do. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Antonio Osuna Posted August 2, 2005 Share Posted August 2, 2005 I think what the Hank/Robinson people are trying to get at is that these people are appreciated for just one thing (Hank for his homers, Robinson for breaking the color barrier) when really there's a lot more they should be remembered for. We remember them as one-dimensional players, when, in reality, they were anything but. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DukeNukeEm Posted August 2, 2005 Share Posted August 2, 2005 Hank Greenburg. Cast aside as because he was Jewish. Served his country. Put up some sick #'s. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts