Guest wsc425 Posted May 27, 2003 Share Posted May 27, 2003 http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/news?slug=seco...v=tsn&type=lgns Firing the manager is the easy way out for underachieving teams, and the White Sox are the American League version of the Mets, only less expensive. They can justify dumping the laid-back Jerry Manuel in the middle of their third consecutive disappointing season. But they shouldn't expect that someone such as Wally Backman, their fiery Class AA manager, will get better results. The White Sox are flawed. Their lineup is too righthanded, their fundamentals too unsound, their chemistry too uncertain. They're bound to start hitting, and maybe they'll add a lefthanded slugger who can play center field and solve two problems at once. But it's always something with this team: a brooding Frank Thomas here, a struggling Mark Buehrle there, one brush fire or another. Eight Sox coaches have been fired since Manuel took over in 1998, three within the past 11 months. The latest casualty is hitting coach Gary Ward, and rival scouts and executives say the switch to the less confrontational Greg Walker is for the better. The move, however, has left Manuel under even greater scrutiny, and a managerial change would shift the focus to general manager Ken Williams. Playing in the game's weakest division, the Sox should not be a sub-.500 team. Williams appeared to build a World Series contender this offseason, trading for staff ace Bartolo Colon and closer Billy Koch and signing setup men Tom Gordon and Rick White. The stunning rise of Esteban Loaiza, a $500,000 free agent, was another Williams coup. Though the exchange of Keith Foulke for Koch in a six-player deal was debatable, few expected Koch to get off to such a poor start -- and the same can be said of White, Buehrle and Jon Garland. Yet, the hitting is even worse than the pitching; at the start of the week, the hapless Tigers were the only A.L. team that had scored score fewer runs. The Sox's on-base/slugging percentage against lefthanders was .796 compared with .694 against righties -- a reflection of their imbalanced lineup. Many in baseball suspect that owner Jerry Reinsdorf will order a July deconstruction for the third time since 1997 if the Sox continue to sputter. The team ranks 25th in the majors in home attendance. Reinsdorf could cut his losses by moving right fielder Magglio Ordonez, who is guaranteed $9 million this season and $14 million in 2004, and Colon, a potential free agent who is making $8.25 million. Williams dismisses such talk. He believes the hitters will perform to their track records; the Sox ranked third in the A.L. in scoring last season, behind only the Yankees and Red Sox. He sees the bullpen stabilizing and the team settling on fourth and fifth starters who can deliver better than a combined 6.00-plus ERA. "I didn't feel it was paramount for this particular team to get out of the gate fast," Williams says. "We wanted to, absolutely. But we think these guys -- with their talent, drive and character -- are built for the long haul. This little speed bump in the road is just that. We trust things will get straightened out." In fact, Williams wants to add rather than subtract, particularly after rushing top prospect Joe Borchard into center following injuries to Aaron Rowand and Willie Harris. The Sox maintain interest in the Cardinals' J.D. Drew and the Pirates' Brian Giles, both of whom could play center. Royals switch hitter Carlos Beltran, a natural center fielder, is an even better fit. But even if Williams is willing to part with the necessary young players, it's doubtful Reinsdorf would add payroll. Reinsdorf might take a different view if the White Sox close on the first-place Twins, but the Sox are 15-29 against Minnesota since the start of 2001. One general manager says the White Sox have "too many guys who don't know how to play." They certainly have too many plodders who would be better off as designated hitters. Williams, however, says the White Sox are no more mistake-prone on the bases than other clubs, and their defensive woes might be overstated. The Sox rank eighth in the A.L. in fielding percentage but fifth in defensive efficiency, a statistic that measures the percentage of balls in play that are turned into outs. If Paul Konerko, Joe Crede and Jose Valentin had on-base percentages above .300, the team's fundamental deficiencies might not be such an issue. Still, the Sox have too many trouble spots. Thomas can't run or play a position and no longer hits well enough to justify the ill will he engenders. One agent calls him as the "big sourball," but good luck to Williams trying to get rid of The Nagging Ache -- Thomas' new contract guarantees him $22.5 million through 2005. Buehrle entered the week allowing 15.03 baserunners per nine innings, the third-highest average in the A.L. His strikeout-to-walk ratio is in decline, from a team-best 2.2 last season to 1.1. The sample size is small; the season is only one-third complete. But if Buehrle isn't the pitcher who won 35 games the past two seasons, the Sox won't be contenders. Manuel is hardly above reproach; a team that lacks leadership needs stronger direction. The Sox, though, would be easier to manage if they had a more balanced lineup and better speed, a Thomas-free clubhouse and a Twins-like defense. Every year they tease their fans. Every year they disappoint them. It's not just the manager. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.