Jump to content

Is this just a coincidence?


jasonxctf

Recommended Posts

im just asking... not attacking.

 

Mississippi weighed in for the sixth year in a row as the fattest state, with 33.8 percent of its adults obese, while Alabama and Tennessee tied for second (31.6 percent). The other top 10, also concentrated in the south, were West Virginia, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Kentucky, Arkansas, South Carolina and Michigan tying with North Carolina for 10th place (29.4 percent).

 

So of the Top 10 most obese/fat states, 8 are deep red states with 1 deep blue and 1 in between. (NC)

 

The healthiest states in terms of weight were congregated in the Northeast and West. Colorado (19.1 percent) came in first, followed by Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Massachusetts, Hawaii, Vermont, Rhode Island, Utah, Montana and New Jersey. The District of Columbia was the only region to experience a decline in obesity rates.

 

So of the Top 10 healthiest states, 7 are deep blue with 2 deep red and 1 in between. (CO)

 

Again is this a coincidence or is their a correlation between lifestyle and political affiliation?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 185
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

QUOTE (jasonxctf @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 10:13 AM)
im just asking... not attacking.

 

Mississippi weighed in for the sixth year in a row as the fattest state, with 33.8 percent of its adults obese, while Alabama and Tennessee tied for second (31.6 percent). The other top 10, also concentrated in the south, were West Virginia, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Kentucky, Arkansas, South Carolina and Michigan tying with North Carolina for 10th place (29.4 percent).

 

So of the Top 10 most obese/fat states, 8 are deep red states with 1 deep blue and 1 in between. (NC)

 

The healthiest states in terms of weight were congregated in the Northeast and West. Colorado (19.1 percent) came in first, followed by Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Massachusetts, Hawaii, Vermont, Rhode Island, Utah, Montana and New Jersey. The District of Columbia was the only region to experience a decline in obesity rates.

 

So of the Top 10 healthiest states, 7 are deep blue with 2 deep red and 1 in between. (CO)

 

Again is this a coincidence or is their a correlation between lifestyle and political affiliation?

I'd say its coincidental, in that certain regions of the country have always tended to be fatter (the South), or healthier (the West and New England). It also happens to be, at present, that the red/blue lines up that way.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (jasonxctf @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 11:32 AM)
i used to think that obesity was tied to weather... cold weather=sit in the house and stay warm rather than walk around, tourist stuff, etc.

 

but looking at this list, it seems like the exact opposite.

 

Look at what they eat down south. This really isn't surprising to me at all. I'm actually surprised Texas isnt on the list since they deep fry pretty much everything haha

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (JorgeFabregas @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 10:40 AM)
I think you might be better off looking at poverty as opposed to red/blue.

 

I'd also wonder about urban vs. rural/suburban.

 

 

QUOTE (ChiSox_Sonix @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 10:49 AM)
Look at what they eat down south. This really isn't surprising to me at all. I'm actually surprised Texas isnt on the list since they deep fry pretty much everything haha

 

Both of these.

 

I lived in Tennessee for a few years, and my god are the diets there awful (on average). Also lived in CO, IA, IL. So I've seen some variety.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (mr_genius @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 11:42 AM)
we obviously need a government program to open vegetable stores in Mississippi.

Well at least they can now save money on oil when deep frying everything. They can walk over to the beach.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not just the deep fried diets. There are 3 other things playing into this:

 

1. Fast food.

2. Sugary Sweets/drinks

3. Lack of exercise options

 

I'm pretty sure that if you plot the numbers for state consumption on the first 2 and exercise time on a map of the states, you wind up with the same basic data as above. It's not just the deep fried okra or the slab of ribs, it's the slab of ribs one day, followed by the McDonalds/Burger King/KFC/Pizza delivery rotation for the rest of the week, with Coca-Cola to wash it down, followed by some time watching the TV.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (jasonxctf @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 10:32 AM)
i used to think that obesity was tied to weather... cold weather=sit in the house and stay warm rather than walk around, tourist stuff, etc.

 

but looking at this list, it seems like the exact opposite.

 

Some of those spots down south, it gets so damn hot & humid, that you can't leave the house or do anything physical outside either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 02:22 PM)
It's not just the deep fried diets. There are 3 other things playing into this:

 

1. Fast food.

2. Sugary Sweets/drinks

3. Lack of exercise options

 

I'm pretty sure that if you plot the numbers for state consumption on the first 2 and exercise time on a map of the states, you wind up with the same basic data as above. It's not just the deep fried okra or the slab of ribs, it's the slab of ribs one day, followed by the McDonalds/Burger King/KFC/Pizza delivery rotation for the rest of the week, with Coca-Cola to wash it down, followed by some time watching the TV.

 

My daughter lives in San Antonio and whenever I visit I am blown away by the number of fast food restaurants in that town. It's insane.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (BigSqwert @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 03:09 PM)
My daughter lives in San Antonio and whenever I visit I am blown away by the number of fast food restaurants in that town. It's insane.

 

I think that's everywhere now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (mr_genius @ Jun 30, 2010 -> 05:42 PM)
we obviously need a government program to open vegetable stores in Mississippi.

 

well, yeah, we could decide to heavily subsidize healthy things instead of corn syrup and meat.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its not just the south. It's that most small towns are just filled with fast food. Usually there is little or no other options.

 

When I went to Tennessee a couple of years ago it was a nightmare trying to find something to eat.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The rate of obesity in the United States has increased to an alarming degree. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention provides data on the state-bystate and nationwide obesity rates. Over the last 20 years, the rates have steadily risen. The nationwide obesity rate is approximately 23.6% (all categories combined – age, sex, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status). This study was undertaken to examine the relationships between obesity rates, per capita income, number of the popular fastfood (McDonald’s) restaurants, and number of whole foods grocery stores per capita. Data from previous

studies regarding the causes of obesity, socioeconomic trends and food selection, state-by state obesity rates, use of federal food assistance programs, and the number of McDonald’s restaurants worldwide and nationwide and “Whole Foods” markets is reviewed. Correlation coefficients were computed to determine relationships between 1) state-by-state obesity rates and per capita income, 2) state-by-state obesity rates and McDonald’s per capita, 3) state-by-state per capita income and McDonald’s per capita, and 4) state-by-state per capita income Whole Foods grocery stores per capita. There

was a statistically significant relationship between the obesity rates and number of McDonalds per capita; the 2 were positively correlated (r=0.27; p There was no significant correlation between McDonald’s restaurants per capita and per capita income (r= -01213, p=0.40). There was a significant, positive correlation between the number of “Whole Foods” grocery stores (r = 0.576, p

per capita income. Results of this study indicate that income, and access to fast food restaurants and whole foods markets have some influence over obesity rates.

Actually can't access this paper from here, but there's the abstract
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Tex @ Jul 1, 2010 -> 09:43 AM)
And the fast food is a result of economics. People with a couple dollars versus people with ten dollars at meal time.

There was no significant correlation between McDonald’s restaurants per capita and per capita income (r= -01213, p=0.40).
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Balta, number of stores doesn't equal level of sales, or % of diet.

 

Look at some of the s***ty neighborhoods in Chicago. There's a McD's every so often, just like the rest of the city, except there ISN'T also a bunch of healthier choices.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Jul 1, 2010 -> 09:51 AM)
Balta, number of stores doesn't equal level of sales, or % of diet.

With a McDonalds though, it's a decent proxy. They take steps to make sure their franchises don't overgrow demand, like occasionally shuttering stores. There's also a ridiculously high startup franchise fee in the way also (5+ years ago it was >$1 million per store franchise fee).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jul 1, 2010 -> 08:53 AM)
With a McDonalds though, it's a decent proxy. They take steps to make sure their franchises don't overgrow demand, like occasionally shuttering stores. There's also a ridiculously high startup franchise fee in the way also (5+ years ago it was >$1 million per store franchise fee).

 

 

Wouldn't most people with a million dollars think twice before committing those resources in a poor neighborhood? It seems like a risk reward formula. Higher risk with higher potential rewards has a store in a poor neighborhood without competition. Lower risk, with lower rewards, operating in a middle class neighborhood.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Tex @ Jul 1, 2010 -> 08:59 AM)
Wouldn't most people with a million dollars think twice before committing those resources in a poor neighborhood? It seems like a risk reward formula. Higher risk with higher potential rewards has a store in a poor neighborhood without competition. Lower risk, with lower rewards, operating in a middle class neighborhood.

McDonald's is unfortunately part of the food pyramid in poor neighborhoods.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...