Keeper Question

[Chi Town Sox]

What would everyone do here? I am torn, you lose the pick that the player was chosen in. Undrafted players you would lose your last round pick

 

This is a rotisserie league so it would be better to focus on just hitters, however, I still have 2 (maybe 3) potential pitching studs that I could get at a good bargain

 

I have the 9th pick, keeping Hanley (1st rounder) and Ryan Zimmerman (13th round), I need to pick 2 others to keep

 

Adrian Gonzalez - 2nd

Ian Kinsler - 3rd

Lincecum - 1st, got him via trade so I would lose my 2nd rounder as I am already keeping Hanley Ramirez

Jon Lester - 4th

Colby Rasmus - 19th

Stephen Drew - Undrafted (probably not with keeping Hanley already)

Drew Stubbs - Undrafted (just named leadoff hitter and went 20/30 last year)

Edinson Volquez - Undrafted

 

I am kicking myself right in the ass because 2 years ago I did not keep A-Gon in the 9th round and ended up taking him anyways (do not ask why because I don't know) - at the time I decided Kinsler was going to explode in 2010, I am leaning towards Adrian since 2nd round may still be a bargain and Stubbs since he can give me superb value losing my last rounder. Rasmus may also be a good value depending on if he can build upon last year (hot to start/cold to end)

 

What does everyone think?

[LittleHurt05]

I'd personally go with AGon & Rasmus, although I think a case could be made for Lester & Stubbs. I wouldn't keep any of the other ones in your situation.

Edited March 22, 2011 by LittleHurt05

[Chi Town Sox]

I'd personally go with AGon & Rasmus, although I think a case could be made for Lester & Stubbs. I wouldn't keep any of the other ones in your situation.

 

Thanks, I think I may go with AGon and Stubbs, I was going to go with Rasmus but Stubbs has gone 30/40 in his first 190 games or so and is now the leadoff hitter. Hopefully it works out