Jump to content

Who would you vote for AL MVP?


caulfield12

Choose one  

59 members have voted

  1. 1. Who's your AL MVP as of today?

    • Jose Abreu
      16
    • Alex Gordon
      1
    • Mike Trout
      35
    • Victor Martinez
      2
    • Nelson Cruz
      2
    • Encarnacion or Bautista
      0
    • Seager or Cano
      0
    • Felix Hernandez
      3
    • Michael Brantley
      0
    • Josh Donaldson
      0


Recommended Posts

Almost impossible to figure out anything more than a Top 5 or so right now...

 

If I was a betting man, I'd say Mike Trout gets it simply for being the overall best player in baseball the last three years, but he's slumped mightily the last couple of months and is K'ing a lot more as well.

 

Sale just doesn't have enough starts, the W-L record or the winning/playoff-caliber team to merit many MVP votes, although he's deserving in his own right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 60
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

MVP is always so subjective.

 

Look at the debate over Andre Dawson back in the date when he was clearly the best player but on one of the worst teams.

 

 

Even with Nelson Cruz's "comeback" season and bulging homer/RBI numbers, a lot of credit there goes to Adam Jones and Pearce as well. It would be harder to pick a "one dimensional" player to some, compared to a Robinson Cano who does everything well and is handicapped by playing at Safeco in terms of his overall offensive numbers, especially homers.

 

The Trout thing's going to be kind of a "first 3 years in the big leagues early lifetime achievement" award, in a way.

 

Of course, Trout's on one of the best teams in baseball now, and Abreu's White Sox are in the bottom 5 for MLB in terms of runs scored/allowed differential. On the other hand, where would the White Sox be without Abreu and Sale?

Edited by caulfield12
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Jose Abreu @ Aug 28, 2014 -> 10:01 PM)
Someone please explain to me without using WAR why Trout supposedly has a huge lead over Abreu. Yes, he is a good baserunner and he fields well, but hitting is the biggest factor in MVP voting, and Abreu has more HR, RBI, and a much better AVG.

Baserunning and defense are still part of the game, and in those two categories he blows Abreu away and adds a ton of value.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Jose Abreu @ Aug 28, 2014 -> 10:01 PM)
Someone please explain to me without using WAR why Trout supposedly has a huge lead over Abreu. Yes, he is a good baserunner and he fields well, but hitting is the biggest factor in MVP voting, and Abreu has more HR, RBI, and a much better AVG.

 

You just explained it to yourself right there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (BaconOnAStick @ Aug 28, 2014 -> 09:13 PM)
Trout just doesn't have the bat. I went Felix.

 

Trout's bat is still mighty impressive. In the AL, his wOBA is an amazing .405 ( I believe league average is around .320 or so), second only to... Jose Abreu

 

If you measure by wRC, an overall measure of runs created, he ranks #1 in the AL. #2 is... Jose Abreu

 

So basically Trout is Jose Abreu playing CF, which is why he is considered so valuable.

 

For the AL I'd go 1. Trout 2. Felix 3. Abreu

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Jose Abreu @ Aug 28, 2014 -> 10:01 PM)
Someone please explain to me without using WAR why Trout supposedly has a huge lead over Abreu. Yes, he is a good baserunner and he fields well, but hitting is the biggest factor in MVP voting, and Abreu has more HR, RBI, and a much better AVG.

He's a better player on a better team, not that hard to figure out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike Trout and it's really not all that close IMO.

 

Cabrera's been awful for his standards this year. Gordon's second in the AL in WAR, but half of that is from his defense (I don't buy it). Cano, Donaldson, Seager, and Abreu are also candidates, but I don't think they can really be fairly compared to Trout.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Jose Abreu @ Aug 28, 2014 -> 10:01 PM)
Someone please explain to me without using WAR why Trout supposedly has a huge lead over Abreu. Yes, he is a good baserunner and he fields well, but hitting is the biggest factor in MVP voting, and Abreu has more HR, RBI, and a much better AVG.

 

You haven't said anything here that is logically valid.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Vance Law @ Aug 29, 2014 -> 12:58 AM)
You haven't said anything here that is logically valid.

 

 

Well, when you compare Miguel Cabrera 2012-2013 with Jose Abreu, there are a lot of similarities, EXCEPT for the strikeouts Jose has accumulated.

 

Both players are/were not noted for their defensive abilities (Cabrera moving back to 3B with the acquisition of Fielder, then from 3B to 1B again, Jose simply adjusting to MLB), although they actually improved and surpassed quite minimal expectations.

 

Of course, Miguel Cabrera was also playing on ALCD winners those two seasons, while Trout's Angels clubs were also-rans.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Vance Law @ Aug 29, 2014 -> 01:58 AM)
You haven't said anything here that is logically valid.

QUOTE (Vance Law @ Aug 29, 2014 -> 01:58 AM)
You haven't said anything here that is logically valid.

Sure he did: Defense & Position probably have little to do with the voting, if anything. You have to do some pretty amazing s*** to win an MVP without being at the top of the triple crown stats along with going to the playoffs. Ichiro, Verlander, Larkin, Pedroia are all outliers compared to typical MVPs.

 

Position matters huh? Look at Barry Larkin's year after he won MVP, 1996. Destroyed his MVP stats from the year before all while playing SS. Well he didn't make the playoffs that year, but the top two in voting did, Caminiti and Piazza. I think more people would argue that Larkin's best season in 1996 was more valuable coming from a SS over a 3Bman...nope.

 

90% triple crown hitting & playoffs, 10% you better not be a DH.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Someone please explain to me without using WAR why Trout supposedly has a huge lead over Abreu. Yes, he is a good baserunner and he fields well, but hitting is the biggest factor in MVP voting, and Abreu has more HR, RBI, and a much better AVG.

 

First of all, Trout has 82 more PA, and playing more should count for something. Trout leads in OBP, SB and Defensive value. Abreu leads in SLG, but that's not enough to overcome all the other defecits.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (caulfield12 @ Aug 29, 2014 -> 03:21 AM)
Well, when you compare Miguel Cabrera 2012-2013 with Jose Abreu, there are a lot of similarities, EXCEPT for the strikeouts Jose has accumulated.

 

Both players are/were not noted for their defensive abilities (Cabrera moving back to 3B with the acquisition of Fielder, then from 3B to 1B again, Jose simply adjusting to MLB), although they actually improved and surpassed quite minimal expectations.

 

Of course, Miguel Cabrera was also playing on ALCD winners those two seasons, while Trout's Angels clubs were also-rans.

 

 

And Trout should have already won the MVP the last 2 years over Cabrera. Trout is getting it. He's the best player in baseball and I don't think it's close.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I voted King Felix. I know Trout will probably win, but Felix is doing some things on the mound that are unparalleled in history, while Trout is having your run-of-the-mill great year.

 

I can see a lot of writers voting for Felix & Kershaw and running with the story. The MLB OPS is the lowest its been in 22 years at the moment, so why not give it to the two pitchers most responsible?

 

/can of worms

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Jerksticks @ Aug 29, 2014 -> 04:51 AM)
Sure he did: Defense & Position probably have little to do with the voting, if anything. You have to do some pretty amazing s*** to win an MVP without being at the top of the triple crown stats along with going to the playoffs. Ichiro, Verlander, Larkin, Pedroia are all outliers compared to typical MVPs.

 

Position matters huh? Look at Barry Larkin's year after he won MVP, 1996. Destroyed his MVP stats from the year before all while playing SS. Well he didn't make the playoffs that year, but the top two in voting did, Caminiti and Piazza. I think more people would argue that Larkin's best season in 1996 was more valuable coming from a SS over a 3Bman...nope.

 

90% triple crown hitting & playoffs, 10% you better not be a DH.

That the MVP has been dumb and arbitrary in the past isn't a reason to keep it dumb and arbitrary now

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (shysocks @ Aug 29, 2014 -> 08:45 AM)
while Trout is having your run-of-the-mill great year.

 

Wouldn't it be sad for Trout if people ended up thinking this way, and he never even ended up winning an MVP? Like he spent his breakout years being "OMG RBI'd" by Miguel Cabrera, and now that his competitor has faded, we're already used to his MVP-level greatness that we never gave him and MVP for, so he bores us too much to get one now.

Edited by Eminor3rd
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Aug 29, 2014 -> 09:17 AM)
Wouldn't it be sad for Trout if people ended up thinking this way, and he never even ended up winning an MVP? Like he spent his breakout years being "OMG RBI'd" by Miguel Cabrera, and now that his competitor has faded, we're already used to his MVP-level greatness that we never gave him and MVP for, so he bores us too much to get one now.

I don't think we have to worry because this is probably his year. The Angels will make the playoffs and that'll be that.

 

Although it would be extra hilarious if writers fall so in love with the KC story that they give it to Alex Gordon, with defensive metrics as the justification.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...