Jump to content

BR ranks the top 10 front line rotations in MLB


thegringokid

Recommended Posts

Hi all, 1st time poster. I know Bleacher Report is to be taken with a grain of salt but it does post some credible metrics in the way the rotations were measured

(WAR, ERA, K9/BB ratio, innings pitched, etc). I'm excited by the fact that apart from anything else, this front 3 should be able to take us deep into games

(I'm talking 6-7 quality innings per start - I.E. we could be among the league leaders in quality starts this year). Couple that with a much improved bullpen (On paper)

& you have the ingridients for a quality season. I would add I am basing this on traditional methods of projecting wins. But I would like to know if the sabre-metric

gurus here agree?

 

Link: http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2347423...ing-2015/page/9

 

Content:

 

Ranking MLB's Top 10 Rotation Trios Entering 2015

 

By

Karl Buscheck , Featured Columnist

Jan. 31, 2015

 

The Trio

•Chris Sale

•Jeff Samardzija

•Jose Quintana

 

Quietly, the Chicago White Sox have built one of the most imposing trios of starters in the majors.

 

It all starts with Chris Sale, who is one of the most underrated pitchers in baseball. The lefty has been an All-Star in each of the past three seasons and was particularly impressive in 2014. Sale ripped off a 2.17 ERA and a 10.8 K/9 ratio, as he landed in third place on the AL Cy Young Award ballot.

 

Sale is also one of the most underpaid pitchers in baseball. In the upcoming season, the 25-year-old will make $6 million. As Sale explained, via Scott Merkin of MLB.com, he's much more focused on bringing a World Series title to the South Side than he is on his bank account: "I don't want the payday. I want the celebration."

 

The White Sox have another under-appreciated lefty on the staff in Jose Quintana. The 26-year-old has topped the 200-innings mark in back-to-back seasons and posted a career-low 3.32 ERA in 2014.

 

Jeff Samardzija, who the club added in a offseason trade with the Oakland Athletics, rounds out the White Sox's top three. Like Quintana, Samardzija had his best season yet in 2014. While splitting the year between the Chicago Cubs and the Athletics, Samardzija recorded a 2.99 ERA. The right-hander, who's set to become a free agent at the end of 2015, also racked up more than 200 strikeouts for the second year in a row.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (thegringokid @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 11:28 AM)
Hi all, 1st time poster. I know Bleacher Report is to be taken with a grain of salt but it does post some credible metrics in the way the rotations were measured

(WAR, ERA, K9/BB ratio, innings pitched, etc). I'm excited by the fact that apart from anything else, this front 3 should be able to take us deep into games

(I'm talking 6-7 quality innings per start - I.E. we could be among the league leaders in quality starts this year). Couple that with a much improved bullpen (On paper)

& you have the ingridients for a quality season. I would add I am basing this on traditional methods of projecting wins. But I would like to know if the sabre-metric

gurus here agree?

 

Link: http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2347423...ing-2015/page/9

 

Content:

 

Ranking MLB's Top 10 Rotation Trios Entering 2015

 

By

Karl Buscheck , Featured Columnist

Jan. 31, 2015

 

The Trio

•Chris Sale

•Jeff Samardzija

•Jose Quintana

 

Quietly, the Chicago White Sox have built one of the most imposing trios of starters in the majors.

 

It all starts with Chris Sale, who is one of the most underrated pitchers in baseball. The lefty has been an All-Star in each of the past three seasons and was particularly impressive in 2014. Sale ripped off a 2.17 ERA and a 10.8 K/9 ratio, as he landed in third place on the AL Cy Young Award ballot.

 

Sale is also one of the most underpaid pitchers in baseball. In the upcoming season, the 25-year-old will make $6 million. As Sale explained, via Scott Merkin of MLB.com, he's much more focused on bringing a World Series title to the South Side than he is on his bank account: "I don't want the payday. I want the celebration."

 

The White Sox have another under-appreciated lefty on the staff in Jose Quintana. The 26-year-old has topped the 200-innings mark in back-to-back seasons and posted a career-low 3.32 ERA in 2014.

 

Jeff Samardzija, who the club added in a offseason trade with the Oakland Athletics, rounds out the White Sox's top three. Like Quintana, Samardzija had his best season yet in 2014. While splitting the year between the Chicago Cubs and the Athletics, Samardzija recorded a 2.99 ERA. The right-hander, who's set to become a free agent at the end of 2015, also racked up more than 200 strikeouts for the second year in a row.

 

welcome to the best sport forum in chi.... ref to your advance metric questions, these guys should be able to answer your question.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Alexeihyeess @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 11:27 AM)
I don't think the Sox top 3 was assembled 'quietly' at all.

 

Sale: not really since he was drafted first round.

Samardzija: not really

Quintana: pretty quiet in the sense two other teams released him and he turned into a gem with us

 

If you're talking about how we acquired them that is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Alexeihyeess @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 12:27 PM)
I don't think the Sox top 3 was assembled 'quietly' at all.

 

Maybe the writer meant to say that all 3 have become White Sox and have not been in the public eye or subjects of media attention like other pitching rotations. I could

guess that would be the case of both Sale and Q (Who have never really demanded or attracted the media spotlight). They just seem to go about their business every

5 days and pitch the best they can. With Shark he does have those 4-5 years of publicity with the Cubs and his distaste for the FO there is well documented and known.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is there a reliable pitching WAR calculator available online? I tried the one on wahoosonfirst.com and it does not come up with a correct number for Sale based on 2014 statistics. I would like to compare the WAR of each of the top 5 rotations cited in this article averaged of the past 2-3 years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (thegringokid @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 09:33 AM)
Maybe the writer meant to say that all 3 have become White Sox and have not been in the public eye or subjects of media attention like other pitching rotations. I could

guess that would be the case of both Sale and Q (Who have never really demanded or attracted the media spotlight). They just seem to go about their business every

5 days and pitch the best they can. With Shark he does have those 4-5 years of publicity with the Cubs and his distaste for the FO there is well documented and known.

Yeah, I think he just means the rotation has not quite gotten the fanfare that it may have if this were another team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (raBBit @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 11:35 AM)
The Cardinals being ahead of us is a joke. Mozeliak would trade his top three for the Sox top three so quick it wouldn't even be funny.

 

Sale>Wainwright

Shark>Wacha (A guy who was hurt most of the year last year and who knows if he would be as good as he was the year before)

Quintana=Lynn

 

I hate the Cardinals

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (BigHurt3515 @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 03:06 PM)
Sale>Wainwright

Wainright threw 240 innings in 2013 and 227 innings in 2014. Sale was better per inning in each season, but Wainright threw 80 more innings than him over those 2 seasons. He's out there more than 20% more innings.

 

For Sale to be better than these guys he can't get hurt. It really is that simple. Right now, Wainright > Sale. Chris can change that by staying healthy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (CaliSoxFanViaSWside @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 05:37 PM)
NL pitchers get the advantage of facing a pitcher a few times a game. Ranking NL teams pitching as superior hardly makes much sense based on that alone.

This is something we can understand the impact of pretty easily. Would you say that Clayton Kershaw would be an average pitcher in the AL? C'Mon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 03:07 PM)
This is something we can understand the impact of pretty easily. Would you say that Clayton Kershaw would be an average pitcher in the AL? C'Mon.

Who said anything about Kershaw being average in the AL ? 9 hitters vs 8 hitters and a pitcher . Abreu at DH , Miggy at DH vs. NL pitchers hitting. C'mon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (CaliSoxFanViaSWside @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 08:39 PM)
Who said anything about Kershaw being average in the AL ? 9 hitters vs 8 hitters and a pitcher . Abreu at DH , Miggy at DH vs. NL pitchers hitting. C'mon.

You specifically said "ranking NL teams as superior hardly makes much sense based on that alone".

 

Based on that, I would conclude that a team with 5 Clayton Kershaws in their rotation should not be called the best staff in the league if it's in the NL.

 

Yes, the NL is easier on pitchers, but that doesn't mean you can't rank them above any AL teams if they're a really good staff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 07:45 PM)
You specifically said "ranking NL teams as superior hardly makes much sense based on that alone".

 

Based on that, I would conclude that a team with 5 Clayton Kershaws in their rotation should not be called the best staff in the league if it's in the NL.

 

Yes, the NL is easier on pitchers, but that doesn't mean you can't rank them above any AL teams if they're a really good staff.

How does a guy like Kershaw stats compare vs AL and vs NL? Is there a noticeable difference in ERA, WHIP, etc?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (JUSTgottaBELIEVE @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 08:55 PM)
How does a guy like Kershaw stats compare vs AL and vs NL? Is there a noticeable difference in ERA, WHIP, etc?

Yes. Kershaw's sub-2 ERAs would probably be just a touch over 2 if he were in the AL and in a pitchers park for his home stadium.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (JUSTgottaBELIEVE @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 10:42 PM)
Not trying to be a smartass. I actually want to know what his splits look like. I can't seem to find that information.

 

In general, all the index stats (anything with a + or -) are league and park adjusted, so FIP- and ERA- would be great places to start comparing NL pitchers to AL pitchers.

 

EDIT: Here's a quick league leaders table I made up with those stats on it: http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=...r=&players=

Edited by Eminor3rd
Link to comment
Share on other sites

QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Feb 1, 2015 -> 05:45 PM)
You specifically said "ranking NL teams as superior hardly makes much sense based on that alone".

 

Based on that, I would conclude that a team with 5 Clayton Kershaws in their rotation should not be called the best staff in the league if it's in the NL.

 

Yes, the NL is easier on pitchers, but that doesn't mean you can't rank them above any AL teams if they're a really good staff.

You can't even quote what I said right when its right there for you to copy and paste . I said " Ranking NL teams pitching as superior hardly makes much sense based on that alone." Left out the word pitching kind of makes a difference even if your response was based on what i actually said and not what you quoted. Every NL starting pitcher doesn't face a DH a couple times a game . Impossible to prove that while NL starting pitchers stats may look better that the pitchers themselves are better based on those stats. But most assume AL starting pitchers do better in the NL and NL starting pitchers do worse in the AL.

 

Saying the top 3 starting pitching staffs are in the NL is just way too hard to quantify because comparing the uncomparable doesnt work. Where you came up with the Kershaw nonsense is beyond me. But maybe it's me and I can't follow your logic or conclusions based on what you think I meant .

Edited by CaliSoxFanViaSWside
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...